What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad thing? If you haven’t encountered it in other classes, react to what you read in the chapter.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 28…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about an...
-
React to day 1 of our documentaries module. One theme of day 1 is that while many docs strive to be factual, they their truths are shaped by...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
One class I discussed individualism in was my Univ 112 class. We went in depth on what individualism was and how it was a core concept in American society. In my words individualism is putting your individual wants and needs first, in contrast to collectivism which is putting the common good first. We talked about the difference between individualistic cultures, like the US culture, and collectivist cultures, like indigenous culture. Individualism wasn't necessarily talked about in a negative way during that class, however, we did talk about the benefits and disadvantages of an individualistic culture. I dont think it's largely seen as a good or bad thing. I think it depends on your feelings about individualism whether you view it as good or bad.
ReplyDeleteDanielle Hall:
ReplyDeleteIn the philosophy courses I have taken, we have discussed individualism a lot. Interestingly, our conversations about individualism differed greatly depending on my professor, which honestly made their political views slightly obvious. In my introductory philosophy course, we were simply given the definition of individualism from a philosophical standpoint, which describes a culture that values independent rights, freedom, and autonomy. This definition, in my opinion, sounds quite positive. In America, we are raised to value individualism. We are taught that the government having too much power is bad and that we have rights as citizens, which is supposedly what makes our country great. These ideals I was raised on, along with my social work perspective, which emphasizes the worth of human beings, made me think individualism was solely seen as positive. In a later philosophy class I took, though, it appeared that my new professor did not see individualism as a positive concept. He talked about individualism versus collectivism and explained that in a self-reliant, individualistic society, people do not look out for each other, whereas in a collectivist society, decisions are made in the interest of the greater good. A culture in which we do not care for others and have to fend for ourselves does not sound as good, although I do not believe that is what an individualistic culture really entails at the end of the day since humans are more complex than that.
One class that talked about individuality was Women and Gender Studies. Individuality was discussed as a big part of America's society or being part of the American dream. It correlated with the saying, "Pull yourself up by the bootstraps." This means if you work hard enough and put in the effort, you will succeed, and your individual work ethic will shine through. In this class it was seen more as a negative topic because that type of individualism can be seen as outdated or unrealistic. This is because not everyone can face every obstacle through willpower alone, especially when systemic barriers are at play.
ReplyDeleteOne class that we talked about individualism was my diversity democracy and ethics class. Individualism was very important to understand in this class because this class was all about learning how everyone is different and unique and their own person. Individualism was seen as a good thing. The class spoke a lot about cultural diversity, personal growth embracing others, which are all huge aspects of Individualism
ReplyDeleteWe talked about individualism culture in America in a class about the climate crisis. We talked about the recycling campaigns in the 90s and the public school curriculums that teach kids about helping the environment by reducing household waste, water usage, etc. We learned that the focus on the individual/household carbon footprints is purposefully emphasized by corporations who benefit from this mindset. The competitive every man for themself rhetoric builds into our culture a natural repellent to collective action, which is one of the only ways to hold them accountable. Climate offenders can then easily put the blame of pollution and waste on the consumer rather than the producer. For example, 80% of water usage in the country is from big agriculture, but when places like Nevada see their reservoirs and lakes drying up at concerning speeds, they place the responsibility on the residents to cut down on water, even though that only accounts for 8% of the total usage.
ReplyDeleteMany High School films, are generally dated, particularly the ones from the 20th century. Some of them have promoted patriarchy, which involves sexism. Some of them have also promoted tobacco smoking, alcohol drinking and other forms of drug use, which has caused very serious health and safety problems, not just for the addicts, but also for the people around them. Movies are like "Monkey See [the movie], Monkey do [the thing(s) they see in the movie]." Movies can send very powerful message and the makers better be careful with what they say.
ReplyDeleteMy names Cole Hundelt BTW.
DeleteI am a theater major and individualism is what they have preached the whole time. One of my professors said “the world is not coming to see a character but they came to see your version of the character.” We were taught to be the best us as much as we could be because if all they wanted were copycats they would never fire people but they want to see your authentic self. I is seen as a good thing but we are also taught to know all of the techniques perfectly so we are the same. It is never truly individualism it is the same actor who knows what they are good or bad at. Being an individual was preached but never truly wanted.
ReplyDeleteThroughout High School, the topic of individualism was brought up quite often. Teachers always encouraged students to be themselves and express who they are, but the lesson never really went beyond these vague mottos. I was taught individualism was important because everyone is unique in their own special way; however I was never really taught how uniqueness improves society or benefits the world in many ways. In my educational career, Individuality has always been presented through empty cheesy slogans that carry no weight to them. Individuality always felt childish in a way that many people would just roll their eyes at. It is not taken very seriously. In my current art classes in my Communication Arts major, individuality is a common theme in assignments where students must speak their truth through their creation and show audiences a lens into our unique perspectives of self identity. I have discussed with many of my peers how school rewards students more for regurgitating information than actually understanding information or adding their own unique input into a project. I often find my peers are more focused on the technicality of projects opposed to putting real individual meaning behind it. Students are more focused on deadlines and formalities to complete the assignment. What the education system pushes for and what people actually fixate on is severely different because the reality is that the education system doesn't view people as individuals, but as numbers. Schools and businesses tend to reward individuals for adhering to the rules and just simply doing the assigned work rather than adding their own opinionated assessment. Social groups also mostly just accept people for following current trends and behaving the same as everyone else. When people express individuality, they are often viewed as weird or an outcast. The reality is that very few new innovative ideas or aspirations become the next Steve Jobs and are able to bend their unique ideas into a sustainable lifestyle. Most people find job security and social acceptance by falling in line with the norm. Schools can preach all they want about the importance of individualism, but it's hypocritical when students' worth is based on a numeral scoring system.
ReplyDeleteOne class of mine that discussed individualism would be my English class in my senior year of high school. I believe it is a great gift to be able to be our own completely unique beings with our own set of experiences and lives. I also think it's wonderful how individuals are able to come together and create things, relate to one another, or even just coexist. However, I will say that the discussion brought up some more negative lights of individualism in society. The idea of having only yourself to rely on is quite scary, especially for those whom luck hasn't smiled upon. Being a part of this society that pushes people to focus on themselves, I understand what it feels like to not concern yourself with the business of others. It can create these lapses of reality where some people may not be aligned with their values, I've seen plenty of people lose their temper on a total stranger. Being yourself is hard, and I think if society could be committed to being more inclusive, respectful, and conscious of one another, people would be able to live more comfortably as individuals.
ReplyDeleteMaya Payne:
ReplyDeleteIn my time here at VCU I haven’t had any classes that discussed individualism and our thoughts about the term and how individualism rules our lives, whether that be if we assimilate or not to a certain ideal or value, because in my major, education, questions like that are not asked but more assumed. On the the other hand, if individualism was talked about it wasn't expanded upon, because I think within the education field I think people assume that all students who want to become teachers have the same ideals, values and thirst for change and never questioning if we may have a different view of how education is going and why "soon to be teachers" should have a thirst for change. Moreover, I don't think individualism is necessarily a bad thing it allows for people to come into themselves and discover what they were mean't to do on this place we call earth and it gives way to creativity, wether that be through fashion, thought, or beliefs. However, individualism can be a bad thing, as talked about in the reading, American philosopher Thoreau explains that being that we live in a materialistic society due to the modern world, in order for one to obtain such materialistic goods and boast about it, one has to conform or assimilate to climb the latter to get to a place where this individual can express their individualism, which is something that think America still deals with today, especially Gen-z.
I've had a handful of classes briefly discuss individualism and the American culture surrounding it. However, my critical thinking course went into a greater depth that was somewhat close to Bulman's description on the topic. We spoke on American individualism and the idea that American ideals are brought up on self responsibility and the idea that we are raised to believe one's success is built on their own merit instead of nepotism. We discussed this to open our minds to our position in life and position of others within our society who were not awarded the same benefits at birth. It was never discussed as a good or bad thing that our culture is so heavily based around individualism instead, it was just used as a teaching moment to discuss our view on the world and to think more critically on how individualism is based within class structure in America.
ReplyDeleteIn my Sociology class last year we talked a bit about individualism. It was talked about in the similar ways Bulman talked about. We brought up topics of social classes & religion. The "American Dream", something we covered in class, is something that goes in hand in hand with individualism in my opinion. As Americans, one of our Nation's founding concepts was the idea of breaking free & being an individual. In this country, there is a lot pushing us into individualism. We hear it in books, movies, schools, etc. In my class, individualism was debated in neither a good or bad way, just simply our ideas on the concept as a whole. I think it's good to have some individualistic values, but too much of it could be damaging. As young students, we are taught to not blend in with the crowd too much, because we need to stand out, especially when looking for a college or job. Independence goes hand in hand with individualism, which is something else our country values highly. I believe individualism is hard-wired into our brains. Even if we are not conscious of it, the idea is constantly around us.
ReplyDeleteThroughout my time in high school individualism was a big topic especially in my marketing/ entrepreneurship class. Individualism was explained as a positive way to boost your self-confidence and be secure within your own ideas and opinions. In this particular class, it was explained as a way to set your self apart from the majority.
ReplyDeleteLeiLani Brewer
Maggi Hubbard
ReplyDeleteUntil coming to college, individuality was almost never discussed in earlier school years. In my high school they never spoke about individualism or the opposite, neither was spoken about much. Coming to college my main course that talks about individualism was Sociology and also my cinema classes, because we have a voice and have something we want to say.
test
ReplyDeleteI have learned and discussed the idea of individualism in my History of African American Civilizations class last year. We spoke about it in terms of African cultures a more collectivist society compared to the U.S where it is more focused on individualism. It is seen to be a great thing in African cultures. I am Somali and my parents did not come to America until about 35 years ago, so my household implements both individualism and collectivism. Both tend to fluctuate from time to time but my parents have exposed us to both as we were growing up as well as now.
ReplyDeleteIn Psychology 101, we did not specifically cover the topic of individualism. However, it was covered throughout the course somewhat. I individualism was brought up in class during topics like self-reliance and when studying how we function mentally. I would say that individuality is largely seen as a good thing because it is largely tied in with being able to express ourselves and be self-dependent. However, I would say that it also can be a bit of a bad thing as well. In my opinion, being able to depend on others and putting others interests before your own can be very beneficial as well. Having a health mix of both is perfect to me.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteI reemeber discussing individualism in an African American studies class. Individualism intersects with various aspects of the African American experience, including culture, history, politics, and identity. We often discussed the term within the context of slavery and the struggle for freedom and civil rights. African Americans were pretty much forced to assert their individuality in oppressive conditions. I think overall individualism is very important to society and is mainly positive.
Individualism has been talked about in many of my classes, not just in college but shockingly in high school too. Many teachers preach that all work being turned in is bound to look different, but they would rather see who we are in our assignments rather than a copy and pasted script of someone else's work. In my theatre classes individualism is at the core of our lessons. It would be unnatural for me to go on stage and try to act the same way my classmates do. That's not what we are there to offer. We are there to show them who we are through our acting and show them how we perceive ieve and react to things. Individualism is at times a skill, something we have to remember to keep practicing no matter how many times we want to just do the easier thing, to go with the masses.
ReplyDeleteMegan McDonough
ReplyDeleteIndividualism has been talked about in a few of my classes. Notably my civics, AP European History, and Government classes. The most recent teaching of individualism I remember was from my government class when talking about conservative and Libertarian ideology. We were taught that individualism is about autonomy and self-reliance- that the government should not interfere with what people choose for themselves. It definitely was not spoken about negatively, we just compared it to collectivism, to find the benefits and downsides of each concept.
During my time at VCU I can't say I've had a class that talked mainly about individualism, but I can say a class that this would of been a good talking point on would of been my Africana Studies class. When talkin about individualism it would of been a great addition to talk about with race and the fight for social equality. Also it would of been a good topic to add on how African Americans had to put emphasis on their individual characters so they wouldn't just be lumped together.
ReplyDelete(Late) When I think about my previous classes and whether or not we talked about individualism I think about my senior year english class. Although it was not a direct topic in class we all understood that each of us experiences our own individual experiences unrelated to another person in the room and because of that it makes us who we are as a person in today's society. I will say that any class that touches on diversity has discussions with individualism as a point to talk about which in my opinion is considered a good thing.
ReplyDeleteA class I've discussed indivualism in has been Focused Inquiry. Most of the discussions have been focused sepcifically on loneliness, but indivdualism and loneliness are separated by a very thin line. Individuality isn't a bad thing, but the difference between being smart with when one is alone and being arrogant has a large impact on the people around them.
ReplyDeleteJimmy McGuinness
DeleteJadyn Cooke
ReplyDeleteWhen individualism was discussed in my classes it seemed to be in a good light but could also become negative in some instances. Such as being able to express oneself and, but it could also lead into loneliness for some people.
I haven’t studied individualism explicitly in a class before(at least not that I can remember), but I found the section on Individualism and Democracy interesting in today’s context. The individuality we are able to feel in a democracy is something that was instilled upon us from the moment we could listen; we were constantly told how grateful we must be that we escaped the trenches of aristocracy. Today though, it feels more common than not to feel distant to the democracy in our country, especially within the republican/democrat party framework. Tocqueville’s concerns of people not seeing themselves within the democratic structure has been realized, but has also been dismissed because of the community these same people find on the other side. To not support today’s democracy is not to find yourself completely selfish and thinking of yourself, but to enter a space with many other people wanting to make change as well.
ReplyDelete