Share something about the film you watched that you hope to discuss in class. Reply to the comments that name your film so that all of the comments for each film are grouped together. Try to include something from what we have discussed so far in this course (e.g, purposes of school, individualism, opportunity, class and race, teacher and/or student agency, the limits of the art form, etc.).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 28…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about an...
-
React to day 1 of our documentaries module. One theme of day 1 is that while many docs strive to be factual, they their truths are shaped by...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
DANGEROUS MINDS
ReplyDeleteJaden Cillo
DeleteThe film I watched was Dangerous Minds. The film is another white savior story that deals with a white woman teaching poor, undereducated, "problem" POC children at an inner-city high school. With her giving it her all, she made these children love learning and care about their futures. It's cheesy and stereotypes different ethnic groups. Though, overall, I have concluded that this movie is more of a call out to the failing education system. You have Emilio, who, in desperate times, goes to his principal for help but is turned away because he doesn't knock before entering, leaving him to take matters into his own hands, which leaves him dead. There's Callie, a pregnant student whom the school is trying to send away because she will give the school an "imperfect image" even though she is a very intelligent individual. Lastly, there is the school board that keeps being brought up, but they are not helpful in the slightest in this whole movie. I think the film had a good message of telling people that they can choose their own paths even though, in my opinion, that's not always true. However, the racial stereotyping and white savior cliche did take away from what the movie was trying to convey.
Megan McDonough
DeleteI watched Dangerous Minds. The thing I wanted to discuss with the class was white saviorism and teacher agency in the movie. I felt that the relationship the teacher had with her students was completely inappropriate. And although at some points her original, off-curriculum lessons did assist students at some points, it is overshadowed by her lack of boundaries. The way she involved herself in students personal lives, showing up unannounced at their homes, taking them out on dates. It felt very unrealistic and has high risks if done in a real-world scenario.
Jadyn Cooke
DeleteI watched Dangerous Minds. The first thing I noticed about the movie is that it was portrayed in a stereotypical way with how they showed the under privileged students and how they showed and talked about their situations. The female teacher brought in to teach them doesn't have the same situation as them and thus can't relate to them. She also acts very unprofessionally by teaching them karate, going to their homes, and trying to act like a cool teacher instead of going into it that way.
LEAN ON ME
ReplyDeleteAudrey MartinSeptember 23, 2023 at 5:59 PM
DeleteI watched Lean on Me. The first thing that this movie highlights that we talked about is the intersection between class and race. Mr. Clark specifically mentions fighting against black people becoming a “permanent underclass”, and the beginning of the movie shows the school in shambles with predominantly black students when it had been a white, rich school decades ago. Because I’m taking a sociology of deviance class, that was the main lens through which I viewed the film. At the beginning, the students were displaying a lot of the stereotypical forms of deviance, such as aggression, vandalism, peer-pressure, and bullying. I also noticed that the teacher employs a lot of structural functionalist approaches to controlling this, especially in his initial mistakes. He uses pure dominance and authority and disintegrative shame to scare the students and even teachers into line. As suggested by lots of sociologists, these tactics alone did not really work. Although removing some of the strained individuals by expelling drug dealers and users did help, it left a sour taste in my mouth to see him turn his back on so many kids and ruin their chances just to improve the school. It felt very utilitarian, like a Thanos approach to expel those kids for the better of the majority of the students. By the end of the movie, he does gradually learn from his mistakes, but the message of the movie is a little clouded by the times when Mr. Clark is randomly pro-establishment even after he’s seemingly learned his lesson. It also never explains his regression over the twenty years that turned him from a rebellious organizer to an institutional discipline machine.
ELLA KATE:
DeleteI watched Lean on Me and I genuinely enjoyed the movie! Something I would like to talk about in the film is the fact that it wasn't a white savior movie. I like the fact that the “savior” was a black man from the same background as the children instead of a random white man from a totally different upbringing as the kids.
Piper Chick:
DeleteI watched lean on me and it was a very good movie. It wasn’t your typical white savior movie but it did have the idea that the low income school made up of majority poc characters needs saving. The methods Mr. Clark uses are in no way legal today. Including putting hands on kids and telling one child to jump and kill himself. He stopped caring about arts because he cared more it seems about their test scores. He cares but his perspective is skewed.
I watched Lean on me and really enjoyed it. It was a good change from the traditional white savior movie. They actually made the "savior" a black man that understood the background of the kids. The methods he used in the movie would of got him arrest and locked up in todays time, but it also makes me think was their any other way to handle the state the school was in. His judgement calls especially coming to working with the other staff made him seem crazy and only care about what himself has to say and do in the matter.
DeleteI watched the movie "Lean on Me," and I thought it was great. I think the movie definitely explored the theme of individualism in a lot of different ways. I feel like Mr. Clark, was depicted as a highly individualistic character. He had a strong personality and was willing to stand up against the school board, teachers, and parents when he believed it was necessary. His ways of going about it may not have always been right, but he didn't conform. Mr. Clark put a emphasis on discipline and high standards, and encouraged the students and teachers to rise above the mediocrity or stigma that was already placed on them as minorities.
DeleteI watched Lean on Me. This seems like a very "ends justifies the means" type of movie, but I found a lot of his methods to be rather in-your-face, militant, and volatile in a work environment, especially in front of kids. First off, his public expulsion of all the "bad apples" as he referred to them was pretty ridiculous. A lot of his methods were extreme, bringing Sam on the roof to make his point and telling him to kill himself was just beyond what I expected out of the hard-ass teacher character type. All of this isn't to say Clark doesn't care for the kids, but he displays his mission to get the school in shape super harshly. Anyway, all's well that ends well I guess, cause he becomes less dictatorial towards the kids while remaining awful to the teachers and staff, but the kids love him and the staff respects his efforts.
DeleteI watched lean on me. I enjoyed watching the movie this wasn’t as typical as old movies tend to be. i enjoyed how he was focused on the students like in the beginning he was encouraging them to learn and be apart of their learning. Although this wasn’t the right approach. He had a goal in the end for the children to pass their test but also create a better environment within the school.
DeleteLeiLani Brewer
STAND & DELIVER
ReplyDeleteDanielle Hall:
Delete"Stand and Deliver" stood out to me in particular because it does not possess the same white savior trope many movies about the education system do, and I felt it was very powerful and well done. Almost the entire film was centered around the relationship between class and race, a topic we have discussed a lot in class. The high school lacked funds and resources, and most of the students were Hispanic. The film demonstrated students’ home lives (in a limited amount of time), and it showed that due to their class and things going on at home, for some of them, their education was not necessarily their priority. There were many assumptions about students due to their race too. Even the main protagonist, Mr. Escalante, joked about his students in a sometimes offensive and stereotypical manner. Additionally, the students are accused of cheating on their AP calculus test, which likely at least partly had to do with their race. Another class topic that was prominent throughout the movie was the purpose of school. In terms of students who originally were putting school on the back burner, Mr. Escalante was able to convince family members (as well as the students themselves) that putting their all into their education was worth it so they could move up in the world and break the cycle of poverty, representing social mobility. Also, mentions of social efficiency were present, as many students had the mentality that they needed to do well in their classes to get a career. Last, when the students faced cheating accusations, Mr. Escalante was concerned that they would lose confidence in the system they are a part of (rightfully so), which I thought brought up ideas of democratic equality. Some other themes that we have noted in class really stood out to me, as well. Expectations for students were hit on, as Mr. Escalante recognized the importance of having high expectations for one’s students. One student when giving up even said, “Everyone knows I’m the dumbest.” Another theme was teacher passion, especially because an older teacher had given up on the school and students in a way, whereas Mr. Escalante came into the school as a new teacher with a lot of hope for the changes he could make. I thought it was also important that the movie touched on teachers overworking since Mr. Escalante ended up having a heart attack. At first, he almost seemed like a superhero with all he was doing, and I think it is important that we remember educators are human, no matter how amazing they are.
In Stand and Deliver there is the usual teacher who comes into a rowdy classroom and makes the kids care trope, but something different I found interesting was the very brief mention of the effects of overworking teachers. Mr. Escalante has a heart attack after taking on many classes to help improve test scores and keep the school’s accreditation. Instead of resting for a month under his doctor’s orders, he leaves the hospital a couple days after his heart attack to go back to the classroom in order to get the kids ready for their AP tests. I think this brings up a common idea of teachers needing to be the one and absolute thing to save students, when resources within a school need to be vast and under many different faculty members and departments. However, I think this speaks very appropriately to the times that we are currently in, where short staffed schools have to rely so heavily on teachers alone because they aren’t given much choice.
DeleteFREEDOM WRITERS
ReplyDeleteThis movie had a very stereotypical white savior story. This movie was about a white teacher who started teaching at a school which had many underprivileged students of color. Throughout the movie it shows the students struggles and how the teacher then helps out by giving them a voice. She gives them journals to write in, she then proceeds to fight to keep her students the rest of highschool and it ends with everyone happy. The ending was very predictable, in class we talked about how many movies dealing with racism and stereotypes follow similar tropes. For example a white person comes in to save these poor children, and helps inspire them and give them a voice!. Although this movie was predictable I would say it was fairly entertaining and I think the movie's goal of inspiring, and expressing issues was met.
DeleteThis movie touched on a few topics we’ve discussed so far: white saviorism, race and class in education, pop culture in education, and the roles of educators. I noticed that the educators in this movie were mostly, if not all, white and were disconnected from the student body which were students of color. Everyone except for Erin Gruwell thought the kids were hopeless and felt that they didn’t need to do anything but teach what was in the curriculum. It was an environment where discipline was more important than a good quality education. There was no respect or understanding between the students or teachers which caused there to be racial tensions. I think the way Erin and the kids were portrayed could have been better; it made it seem like Erin was an overly optimistic superhero and always swooped in to save a student’s day which is unrealistic. I also think the pace in which trust was established was unrealistic too, but they had to fit in there somehow. In addition, the fact that the teacher said “I know what you’re up against” to one of her students who was dealing with his brother being incarcerated was also far fetched because she doesn’t have to live with the stuff her students are dealing with from day to day. I liked how pop culture was incorporated into the education and how she pushed for the kids to go on a field trip. I think it’s important for kids to explore other places outside of their hometown, especially if that’s where they’re experiencing hardships.
DeleteMaya Payne
DeleteErin Gruwell started teaching as a first-year teacher in 1994 and in the movie this is where her journey starts and we, as the viewers followed. The movie proceeds to show the stereotypical students she’s going to be teaching, low-income and minorities, trying to change them for the better, being seen as their white savior or the great white hope to propel them to the next level, graduating. Gruwell then comes to an understanding that teaching the way she trained to teach wasn't going to work, so she had to come up with different ways to captivate their attention, playing the 2pac song, the line game to then giving them a journal to write in for daily entry’s. Nevertheless, having Erin as their teacher not only allowed them to learn and excel in reading and writing, but to also understand the importance of writing.
Circling back to the white savior aspect, Erin is the portrayed as one, to help and save these teens from their background and unjust school, that the go to and are part of, it's predictable. After watching this film, I hope to talk about the art form used to help minorities in movies, and whether it helps or hurts to get the point across, such as in this film using poetry to help Erin understand what her students are like outside of the educational environment and why they are reading and writing at below grade level.
I watched Freedom Writers because I had heard a lot about it through TikTok and English classes. Almost from the first scene I could map out how this movie was going to go. A new teacher who was not accustomed to the hard knocks would be thrown into a school that would push her to limits because of the students opposition, but she would overcome that and help them. Happily ever after. I wish that this movie was more complex in plot. One thing I think that was depicted well in this movie was the lack of education for minority students in schools in poorer areas. All of the minority students had not heard of the Holocaust, which is a major event in human history. I'm not sure how realistic this actually is, but still, many kids are growing up not being taught things that they should. Also, the fact that all the students gave their notebooks in and told her their secrets was quite unrealistic in my opinion as well. Either way, whether the movie was realistic or not, I still enjoyed the messages throughout it. Freedom Writers did clearly display white saviorism, however do the positive messages outweigh this? I'm still unsure.
DeleteI think Freedom Writers had many important topics that we discussed such as racial issues & stereotypes, white saviorism, class, & pop culture. I liked that the film told stories that are a very real reality for lots of kids, although I think there were definitely some unrealistic things that occurred. There was representation of multiple minority groups which I think is important. We also saw kids living in impoverished conditions. Pop-culture was included in the film when Mrs. Gruwell tried to include songs & movies in her curriculum that her students would relate to like Tupac & Boyz N the Hood. Although parts of the movie could be unrealistic or predictable I do think that it got through many of its viewers & spread light on harsh topics that someone with different privileges may never think about.
DeleteFreedom writers depicted many subjects that we discussed in class such as white saviorism, class and race, opportunities, and classism. Something that stood out to me about this movie would have to be the pattern regarding the immense dislike the students have for the teacher. These kids may have had their issues with each other, but together, they understood each others struggles within the school system and life itself. To them, Mrs. Gruwell is the white woman who tries her best to understand what they're going through while coming from a picture perfect background. To their surprise, she was able to win them over by her unique teaching style and her effort to try and help them out as best as they can.
DeleteTO SIR, WITH LOVE
ReplyDeleteDylan Crider
DeleteI watched To Sir, With Love and I had a pretty decent understanding of how the movie was gonna go when i read the description and it being a reverse race typical urban school story where the teacher was black helping a bunch of poorer white students. The biggest crux of the movie was the class of the students where they felt that no one really wouldve cared if they succeeded especially given the one male student who was the one that truly didnt wanna change even while everyone else in the class was. So just like Bulman talked about with individuality being a huge thing in the urban school style of movie, it was pretty true here with that one male student even though all of them were poorer and didnt have the best home lives and the teacher still was trying to set them up to be a successful adult.
^^ Michelle Ghee
DeleteOne moment within To Sir, With Love that has stuck with me after my viewing is Thackeray's declaration of how his classroom will be run. After endless barrages of insults and lackluster behavior is thrown his way he finally breaks down the wall of hierarchy the students believed they had upon him. You would suspect any teacher to declare their superiority over the classroom to demand their respect, and Thackeray does this by coming to an understanding with his students. They believe themselves to be an unheard and misunderstood generation, but Thackeray begins by giving them the respect within his classroom he himself has not been given and giving them a platform to learn the "real lessons" that Thackeray has for them. Building a bridge for connection from the students own uniqueness and the respectability that society demands of them.
Delete(Late) I watched To Sir, With Love and as a basic review I will say that it wasn't a bad movie, there were just a few things that stood out as weird to me. Thackery's approach to teaching these children did not work the children at first so he switched to treating them like adults and giving them real life lessons rather than actual school lessons. He treated them with respected and expected the children to also treat each other with respect. The movie just depicted this as a saving grace, "like oh I know how to call someone sir and make a salad now I can be a productive member in society." It would be nice if that was true but it wasn't too practical. I will say I did not hate the movie and I'm actually glad I picked this one because it wasn't like most high school depicted movies.
DeleteThe movie I decided to watch was To Sir, With Love. I had no prior knowledge of what this movie was about other than that my dad loves it and that he has been telling me to watch it for years. After the movie I seriously questioned why he likes it so much, because I found it to be very boring. However, personal opinions aside, it was a perfect movie for this class. It covered many of the issues we discuss during class such as, race and class, the purposes of school, and that teacher heroism we mentioned being a staple in education related media. Thackery getting assigned a class of students who refuse to change their ways and adhere to his standard miraculously changes their lives by the end of the movie by teaching them how to make a salad, not be a slut, and not fight teachers. By teaching them things that they will actually need for the real world that they are about to step into, they realize how Thackery is the best teacher they've ever had and conclude that they will miss him, but since he never really wanted to be a teacher he is packing up and going to a new job. Overall, this movie was a little weird to me and had me raise my eyebrows quite a bit. Very interesting.
ReplyDeleteMaggi Hubbard
ReplyDeleteFreedom Writers
For my film I feel like it's very obvious this is set in 2007. I want to say I liked the film but the stereotypes were too much for me. All the white people in the honors classes and the only white kid in Mrs. G class only relating to the drug aspect of things. I feel like this relates to a lot of things we've learned about in class when talking about the urban and suburban cities and their schools. also the difference between private and public schools and the sterotypes of those. This took me back to the episode we watched in class of the teachers trying to make a change (I can't remember the name). but the stereotypes in the show were not near as bad as freedom writers. a lot about the movie made me cringe in a way of how the hispanic woman had a father in jail and the gang relation. for a movie during this time I feel like it might've opened the minds of people but not in the way it should've.