How was student agency depicted in the film you watched? You might describe and react to student agency in the film or compare characters in the film and whether/what kinds of agenda they possess. Feel free to also suggest topics for discussion when we meet to discuss.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 28…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about an...
-
React to day 1 of our documentaries module. One theme of day 1 is that while many docs strive to be factual, they their truths are shaped by...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
I think Clueless was very well done. It may be cheesy for some. It was kind of, but with better pacing. I do feel like Cher trying to argue her way with her teachers just to improve her grades was unrealistic, because even if you could make them an offer they can't refuse like in Godfather, they are not gonna change the grades. I did like the part were Cher looks at boys in the 90's and says "So okay, I don't want to be a traitor to my generation and all but I don't get how guys dress today. I mean, come on, it looks like they just fell out of bed and put on some baggy pants and take their greasy hair - ew - and cover it up with a backwards cap and like, we're expected to swoon? I don't think so." I could agree because I feel like not only is that dated, but it is too obvious and unsurprising.
ReplyDelete"Class Rank" is a 2017 film directed by Eric Stoltz, written by Benjamin August. While the film primarily focuses on the theme of high school politics and class rank, it does touch on student agency, although it may not be the central theme. Student agency refers to students' ability to take an active role in their education, make choices, and have a say in their learning experiences. In the context of the film "Class Rank," we can observe elements of student agency in the following ways:
ReplyDelete1. Veronica's Determination: Veronica, one of the main characters, demonstrates a strong sense of student agency throughout the film. She actively seeks change within her high school by running for the school board and advocating for a reform of the class rank system. Her determination to challenge the status quo and improve the education system is a clear example of student agency. She is not content with passively accepting the rules but instead takes proactive steps to make a difference.
2. Bernard's Character Arc: Bernard, the other main character, initially appears disinterested in school and disconnected from the education system. However, as the story progresses, he develops a sense of agency. He becomes more engaged in his education and takes ownership of his future, partly because of his growing relationship with Veronica. This transformation illustrates how student agency can be sparked or encouraged through interpersonal connections and exposure to new ideas.
3. School Board Elections: The central plot of the film revolves around the school board elections, where students have the opportunity to influence the direction of their school. This storyline highlights how student agency can manifest through democratic processes, where students actively participate in decision-making.
While "Class Rank" does portray elements of student agency, it also contrasts different characters and their agendas:
1. Veronica represents the agenda of educational reform and a desire for a fairer system that doesn't solely rely on class rank.
2. Bernard, initially seen as apathetic, eventually develops an agenda of self-improvement and a desire to escape the constraints of his overbearing mother's expectations.
3. Bernard's Mother stands in contrast to her son's growing agency. She has a rigid agenda for her son's life, which initially suppresses his individuality and agency.
4. The School Board Members have their own agendas, some of which align with Veronica's vision for change, while others resist it to maintain the status quo.
In reaction to the student agency depicted in the film, it's important to acknowledge that it highlights the power of individuals to effect change within educational systems. Veronica's determination and Bernard's transformation serve as inspirational examples of how students can take ownership of their learning experiences. Overall, "Class Rank" provides an interesting exploration of student agency, particularly in the context of challenging traditional educational norms and advocating for reform. It showcases how the actions of determined individuals can have a meaningful impact on their educational environment and the lives of their peers.
I watched the movie clueless, this movie showed how when it comes to movies about a student certain values are considered "important" such as popularity, being in a relationship, not caring for grades, and coming of age. Another part of this movie was the main character Cher, had the stereotypical rich dumb girl who somehow always got her way through persuasion, for example she would bribe teachers to raise her grade. Although lots of the movie was her in school, it was focused more on her social life, which is the opposite of movies with the main character being a teacher which solely focusses on school. Movies like these show the stereotypes for teachers vs students.
ReplyDeleteDanielle Hall:
ReplyDeleteStudent agency is depicted in “Class Rank,” as the entire film is centered around students attempting to take their education into their own hands. The main characters, Bernard and Veronica, both display student agency. Bernard goes to every meeting held by their school board and even tries to become a member of the board with Vernoica’s help. Veronica, after finding out that her class ranking may hurt her chances of getting into her dream school, chooses to become involved in campaigning for Bernard so he can get rid of class rankings at their school altogether. I noticed, though, that the students in the film did not actually have many opportunities to demonstrate their agency. While Bernard showed up and spoke at every school board meeting, the board members did not take him seriously or take his suggestions into consideration. Bernard was allowed to run for the school board, which the students seemed excited about eventually because they realized they would really have a voice in their learning. That being said, no adults wanted Bernard to actually get that chance, and he ended up not receiving a position on the board. Rather, the board kept the same members it had had for years, meaning no new perspectives were being brought in and no change or growth would be made toward the student body’s interests.
Something else that I found interesting while watching the film was the differences in motivators between the two main characters. Bernard is interested in making changes to the system, as he was taught a passion for being involved in his education from a young age. Even if he sometimes seeks changes due to his own self-interests, he prioritizes his work lobbying and trying to make policy changes over his schoolwork. Veronica wants to go to a good college, so everything she does is for school. Any good she does is to look good on her transcript, and there is even a line in the movie in which she suggests that she would not have helped with the Special Olympics if she knew it was not for extra credit. It turns out that Bernard is actually ranked first in their class, making Veronica second (the moment that gave her a sense of agency because she felt as though the system let her down). I think this discusses the fact that someone can be a good student and have a life outside of school, which is important for us as a workaholic society to talk about, in my opinion.
Clueless is a film with a high school setting which focuses on a student as the protagonist, Cher. One of Cher's main conflicts involves her school work, but the way she goes about fixing her problem greatly differs from the teacher-centric stories last week. Cher seeks better grades not by doing hard work, instead she uses social skills such as persuasion, manipulation, and charisma to get her way. Even though this conflict is based around classwork, the main focus of the story is on Cher's high opinion on popularity. Cher is portrayed as cool and admirable through her charisma, wit, luxurious life, so when she values parties, boyfriends, and being popular over education, audiences in turn internalize these beliefs similarly. Even other students in the background can be seen obsessing over appearances and not caring about class. Many of the girls had plastic surgery bandages and constantly fixed each other's hair and clothes. During class many of the students were visibly tired and uninterested. Cher didn’t even conduct any research for her debate speeches and many students applauded her. Cher even fixes her grades in this class by applying an ideal that the film depicts as more important, love and being in a relationship. School is more viewed as a setting for the story and a small obstacle in a high schoolers life opposed to a main importance. Cher understands she needs to have good grades, but doesn't actually care about learning the material or even taking the lessons seriously. The teachers are depicted as goofy and gullible. The teachers do not have a lot of depth. They're archetypes of old stuck up and easily manipulated. Despite this film coming out before I was born, throughout school my peers all knew and loved the film. My schools have similar values of being cool and popular. Like Cher, students at my school often only cared about good grades and not actually learning material. This film's definitely impacted how students view school. Stories like these push the agenda of social appearances being more important than education.
ReplyDeleteIn Clueless Cher reasons that she is only getting bad grades because her teachers are miserable. Therefore, one agenda Cher poses in Clueless is trying to get two of her teachers to date to be able to make them happy; which in turn would make her get good grades because the teachers would be focused on their happy relationship instead of grading papers. Another character that has an agenda would be Dion. She and Cher transform a new student into someone who they think would be popular. They do this in the interest of using their popularity for "good". These agendas are a lot different from the ones we see the teachers have in the previous films.
ReplyDeleteIn Class Rank, student agency is depicted by two characters, Veronica and Benard. You have Veronica, the school president, who wants to abolish the class ranking system so it won't show on her Yale application. To do this, she gets Benard to run for the school board. Benard has been attending every school board meeting since he was eight years old and always makes sure his voice is heard. He wants bike lanes for the roads and for them to stop teaching French and instead Mandarin. However, both of their goals are selfish, as Veronica is only getting rid of the class ranking for herself, and Benard only wants bike lanes for his bike and Mandarin to be able to speak to his girlfriend. Though, I do believe Benard does care about actually making a change to the school system, especially when he does his speech in front of the school and when he does the speech in front of his competitors. He shows genuine compassion for what he is talking about.
ReplyDeleteWhen it comes to the school board, they never really listen to what Benard has to say. As they see his request as outlandish and probably not within their budget. At the end of the movie, nothing school-wise really gets accomplished. Benard never became part of the school board, and none of the policies they wanted ever went into place. I found that disappointing because no real change was made in this movie.
Forgot to put my name.
DeleteIn Ferris Bueller's Day Off, student agency was depicted in different ways. I really enjoyed this movie, it's like a comfort film. Ferris just wants a day off school. He ends up convincing his parents to let him stay home because he is "sick". Word gets around school that Ferris is "deathly ill" and we see students collect money for him. The town water tower even says "Save Ferris" on it. It seems like the students tend to get away with a lot in this film, or rather the faculty seem to be mindless. Ferris even hacks into the school's system and changes his grades, as well as the amount of days he's been absent for. The dean of students, Ed Rooney is out to get Ferris and spends the whole day trying to catch him in the act of ditching school. I think we could talk about how realistic or unrealistic this movie is in class.
ReplyDeleteI watched Ferris Bueller's Day Off. This movie was all about agency and free will from the very start. One thing that really interested me is that when Ferris and his friends set out to do anything they wanted in the city for a day, they spent it engaging with art, music, and sports. Although it paints school as a soulless vacuum of spirit, the message of the movie is more of a critique of the mindset that comes out of the school-to-work pipeline of productivity and exploitation over all else. The principle caring so much about expelling one of his students and even ruining his future is the personification of this. The conflict with Cameron and his dad's car is also very wound up in meaning because he eventually realizes that the attachment his dad has to this material item has been prioritized over his love for his son. At the end of the movie, Cameron destroys the car, which his dad would be furious about, but it's treated as a happy moment. He decides to confront his dad about their relationship now that this barrier between them has been broken down.
ReplyDeleteMichelle Ghee:
ReplyDeleteI watched Ferris Bueller's Day Off, which to me had a lot of really interesting conflicting things to say about individualism. Its most obvious message is one that schools are ways of destroying individualism, as represented by Ed Rooney being a force for conformity in Ferris' life. In this view, Ferris is the ultimate force for individualism, all the way down to him saying he doesn't believe in "isms", just himself. However, I do think that Ferris is also something of a conforming force. For all his references to the self-expression of the 60s, the way it's used in the film is to get everyone to the same "Save Ferris" nexus point, even after people rightfully critique him as selfish and inconsiderate. It's reflective of a very Reagan-era philosophy--Ferris' status as a supposed underdog to the education system isn't about fundamentally critiquing its merits as a social institution, but about the fact that it doesn't let him do what brings him the most immediate satisfaction, even at the expense of others. Even with this in mind, it's still one of my favorite movies ever. I think this comes back to the question we've been asking in class: if we know that these movies often bend the knee to such problematic philosophies, why do they become such cornerstones of pop culture? Why is Ferris still so much fun?
Moxie is a great movie to talk about student agency. Fun fact I had to look up what student agency meant and was confused when an over sea travel agency came up. The girls in this film are tired of being objectified and the double standards and decide to do something about it. Schools do not allow people to have a say and are picky on which rules they actually choose to enforce. The rules are often sexist, homophobic, and transphobic. Dress code for example is sexist. In my high school guys could wear short shorts and no one cared. If a girl wore a dress and it rode up when walking up the stairs it was an immediate in school suspension. In the movie one of the things they protested was dress code by having the girls wear tank tops which guys were already wearing throughout the movie. They talked other things like girls having to fight harder to be considered for the same opportunity. Another thing would be someone who is trans being excluded for things like not being able to audition for the female lead or being dead named. Some characters are extreme like Vivian the girl who started moxie did go to extremes and yelled at people who cared about her along her frustrations out on them. That frustration and the need to have someone hear them even if it’s being taken out on the wrong person or thing. It covers real topics and issues in schools like how they diminish the seriousness of problems like harassment, bullying, and sexual assault to keep face. They not only banded together to fight their school but they supported each other. They had a voice by banding together almost like the who’s in whovilles.
ReplyDeleteI watched Clueless, and the first thing I noticed was the runtime. At an hour and forty odd minutes, I didn't think much of a story could be produced well, but I found myself enjoying the movie more than I thought I would. The characters were cheesy, the dialogue was corny, but for some reason I thought it fit the story very well. I liked how colorful the characters were, in both a literal and figurative sense. Cher takes herself seriously, and unlike the trope of "rich girl gets what she wants by whining and bullying", Cher WAS a rich girl with a big powerful lawyer father, but she was smart about how she got what she wanted. She observed her teachers as people, and confidently used that to her advantage without malice.
ReplyDeleteJimmy McGuinness ^
DeleteThere was also a lot of radiohead in this movie.
DeleteI watched Moxie. The girls in this movie were experiencing normalized sexual harassment, degradation, and were silenced. Vivian, who’s the main character, grows tired of being disregarded and starts a feminist movement called Moxie to give the girls a voice and to call out the school’s sexism. It started with drawing stars and hearts to show support for the girls then posters were made, they created an Instagram page, they protested the dress code, and they organized a walk out. They wanted to show that the school shouldn’t value the guys more, and the girls should be heard and respected. Overall, the message was positive, the issues in the movie were accurate, and I liked seeing girls my age fight hard to support one another.
ReplyDeleteWithin the 2017 film "Class Rank" student agency is depicted as the students take the future of their own education and their peers education into their own hands as the main character bernie runs for the local student board. Bernie is an active member in local politics since a very young age, he's very educated on its in's and out's and is very opinionated on how to better the lives of his local community. He is ushered to run by his classmate Veronica as she too takes the future of her education into her hands, wishing to abolish the class rank system believing it to be unjust. Both are often not taken seriously when they wished to take control of their own education. As they are both young they are believed to be naive to how the systems work and unable to make real social change for their own betterment. It's not until they realize their own abilities to change their personal lives do they realize they actually have a shot with this election. Their peers rooting for them, hoping for a bright new face to be the voice of their generation as Bernie goes from a bullied outcast to a well respected individual and others notice the budding romance between him and Veronica. But in the end no adults wished to give the newcomer a shot and everything remains the same as Bernie loses the election. No real change is made for the students but a major change in the personal lives for all characters is ahead of them. I think it's interesting to leave the film on that note as most of the film is driven by selfish wants for betterment. Veronica is driven by making second place on her class ranking and wishes to abolish the whole system instead of swallowing her pride and trying again later. Bernie is way more involved in local politics but is motivated by selfish wants as well disguised as betterment for his entire community, wishing for policy changes within the school board and improved bike lines for his commute to school and around town. The film ends with no change made for the students in the larger community but a budding romance and the ability to go to college and come back more educated and able to seize the opportunity later on leads to a possible bright future for Bernie and Veronica.
ReplyDeleteI watched the movie Moxie and I believe it did a good job at depicting student agency. Vivian (our main character) is pretty much “awoken” by the new girl Lucy about problems regarding the ladies at the school, especially since the school's jocks put out a derogatory list about the ladies. The ladies are tired of the double standards and the constant objectification that goes on in the school so they ban together through the anonymous feminist group Moxie. I think it did a good job showing what happens when girls come together and stand for something they know and feel is not right and unfair. Although I was expecting it to be a corny movie about some issue in high school it’s honestly the opposite. I feel like they added the right amount of corniness to make you almost not notice but they got the point across in a perfect way in a high school setting.
ReplyDeleteIn the movie the breakfast club student agency is shown by a group of five students. All students come from a different type of group within the school and before today they have probably never interacted with each other. What brings them together is detention on a Saturday morning. As the day goes on and they are stuck with each other they come to the conclusion that although they don’t hang with the same people they have many things in common. The only thing that differs for each student is what they have been through and the experience they have that makes them different from the others. They all have a unique story.
ReplyDeleteLeiLani Brewer
I watched the movie Breakfast Club which brought together students who were all very different for an eight-hour Saturday detention. As they navigate each other personalities, they go from laughing about hidden talents to serious discussions about their personal lives in the span of minutes. In my opinion, the acting was not the best at times, almost too stereotypical (even though I understand that was part of the point of the movie). All in all, I thought this movie was pretty good in terms of depicting how a meeting of five so different people would go at times. Breakfast Club was overall a movie that I enjoyed for it trying to navigate how five different people that would never talk to each other in school would go.
ReplyDeleteThe movie I watched was moxie and I had seen this movie before, but ive seen all the other movies before but I chose moxie because the first time I watched it I felt a sense of women empowerment. in the film the main character created a feminist group for women in highschool to allow a safe space for women who feel objectified and targeted by the men in school. the film was not corny for a Netflix movie and I feel like the film advocated for feminists properly.
ReplyDeleteAgency is portrayed quite a bit throughout the breakfast club. The main characters of the movie were forced to write a 1000 word essay describing who they are as a person. In their time together, these kids spent their time hanging out and having fun with the time that they had together. During this time period, they confided in each other and warmed up to one another because they were able to bond over the struggle in their lives and be themselves around each other. This caused the group to seriously reflect on who they were individually instead of how society portrayed them.
ReplyDeleteI watched The Breakfast Club. The main theme of the movie is coming together despite different backgrounds. Five teenagers end up in detention together and they are all from different stereotypical groups represented in high school. There's a jock, weirdo, bad boy, popular girl, and a nerd. By the end of the movie they become and unlikely group of friends that never would have happened had they not bonded during their eight hour detention. Some even grow into a quick relationship that I personally doubt lasts more than the kisses they exchanged in front of their parents at the detention pick up line. Student advocacy in this movie looks like these kids taking what their school and parents have made them out to be and turning into who they really are and opening up about what they are actually going through. The nerd feels the weight of the world on his shoulders and all the pressure from his parents and his mental health suffers because of it. The popular girl struggles with how her family treats her and all she is thought of is as a good girl with no personality, so to beat this she falls for the bad boy? As for the bad boy, he has a lot of home life struggles and puts up an act at school to cope with this. However, it is very obvious that the school and assistant principal don't do anything to help him or motivate him out of the cycle he is in. In fact, there are many times Vernon (the assistant principal) uses his power to threaten the bad boy and to prove that he will always be below him and anybody else he tries to go up against. Overall, this movie focuses a lot more on the students perspectives on things rather than a teachers. I have always enjoyed this movie!
ReplyDeleteMegan McDonough:
ReplyDeleteI watched The Breakfast Club. The overarching theme has a lot to do with these students agency, and how much agency they have. Although in the beginning it may seem like these kids have a lot of agency in defining themselves, and their cliques, the level of control they have over their own lives comes into question. It seems like they do not really have control on how they are perceived, due to both parental and academic pressures. Andrew and Brian are deeply defined by their parents expectations. Brian cannot help being perceived as a sheltered bookworm, because his parents push him to make school his entire life. And Andrew also is pressured by the school, his coaches all have expectations for him to focus and excel in athletics. They note that he makes no choice for himself. So in reality, he doesn't seem to have much agency at all. Even characters like Bender, who seem to use their agency to push against every societal standard, are pressured by their environment. His fathers treatment imprints on him, and changes his character.
The movie I watched was the Breakfast club. It is a movie about 5 students who have Saturday detention and so happen to come from different social classes. The movie really helped depict the different environments students are having not just in school but outside the schools and the social pressure that comes with it. We see an example of this with the jock Andrew, his dad who pressured him to be a wrestler for the school and the reason why he’s in detention is because he beat up a “weaker” kid to try and impress his dad. The movie showed that by learning about each other's experiences they learned that they all go through a lot of the same things and that they are more alike than they thought. The detention ended up giving them a chance to understand each other and change their outlook on the rest of the kids in their school and different social classes.
ReplyDeleteI watched Ferris Bueller's Day Off, which had a great amount of agency. For Ferris, his desires and choices are so grandiose and drastic that his agency is certainly the greatest out of any other characters. Cameron also finds some agency by getting the courage to destroy his dad's prized car, which was driving a wedge between him and his dad. This isn't to say Ferris doesn't coax Cameron into nearly every decision in the movie and strings him along through all his schemes. The movie was basically all sunshine and rainbows, as the kids have an incredible fairy tale day out in Chicago and still don't caught in the end.
ReplyDeleteI watched The Breakfast Club and I think student agency can be depicted in the film through the message that young people have the power to challenge stereotypes, question authority, and discover their true selves. Individuality and the idea that students should have the agency to shape their own identities is represented in this film. I think each character in the film battles with their own personal identities. For example Andrew seeks to break free from the pressures of being a "jock" and pleasing his father. Whereas Bender appears to have a more confrontational agenda, wanting to push back against anyone who tries to control him. Overall, "The Breakfast Club" portrays student agency through self-discovery and just breaking down stereotypes.
ReplyDelete