Tuesday, August 22, 2023

September 6…Hollywood Goes to High School

Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.)  in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. Note: If you absolutely can’t find something to disagree with, feel free to write about that situation (why you can’t disagree) or simply discuss something that you found interesting in Ch. 1.

20 comments:

  1. Danielle Hall:
    I will admit that it was difficult for me to find something in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Through other courses I have taken, particularly anthropology, I have come to the belief that the success of different films throughout time says a ton about that society’s culture. That being said, this is specifically the case when it comes to films that have an underlying message. While most movies do have a theme, a bias, or even a political message, some movies are really just for entertainment. There are some successful films that I simply am unsure one could genuinely come to a significant conclusion about a society from. For example, the Mario movie this year saw a lot of success, but I do not think anyone could determine a lot about our culture from it. As a society, we love Mario and video games. Maybe one day it will not be okay to impersonate an Italian accent, and something could come from that. But overall, I do not think our love for that movie will be all that beneficial to individuals studying our society’s beliefs and values. Currently, I feel as though using movies to make broad generalizations about society only works with certain types of movies; although, I would definitely be interested to see one day if my statement is wrong (and I would not be all that surprised if it is to be completely honest).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I honestly can't find anything I disagree with their explanations, and the research is very sound and on point to what I would consider the school genre to be like. The school genre is mainly about a person trying to find themselves or break away from the social norm. Everything they said kind of just reminded me of early to mid-2000s Disney Channel movies and shows. You have your character, which is usually middle to lower-middle-class, and trying to find themselves in high school while dealing with external and internal conflicts, such as hiding some secret or coping with the death of a parent. Some examples are That So Raven, Hannah Montana, Radio Rebel, Zapped, Lemonade Mouth, Another Cinderella Story, etc. These shows or movies also have a message they're trying to convey to the viewer, and it's usually along the lines of don't be afraid to be yourself. I also found it interesting that they discussed how these types of movies depict teachers. I never thought about it, but the school genre often makes teachers the wielders of all wisdom or the obstacles in a student's path to success.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For me, this kind of describes how I feel about movies in general and I have kind of felt this way for a long time. There are many types of films in the world. There are some sci fi and fantasy and even comedy and musical films that are made for us to escape the real world for our own personal enjoyment and imagination. Some of those films can also be used to describe parts of the real world, at least some of the ones that are made today. There are also more dramatic and realistic films meant to directly address the problems of the real world in order to fight them. Then there are ones that are realistic but fictional and dramatic in order to test our emotions and our ways of thinking. But these films are not always accurate about what happens in the real world. The sci fi and fantasy films are definitely and obviously not from the real world, given the fact they break the laws of physics too far. The ones about the real world are not always accurate either. Sometimes if the film is based on a true story and sometimes events and even characters are made up to dramatize the story and, in some cases, protect the innocents. The dramatic and more realistic ones are not always accurate either, because sometimes there are things in there that don't happen in the real world, even if they look realistic. So in summary, whether it's films depicting teachers, homeless and lower class people, or any hard thing in the real world, the films try to be real as possible, but they do make mistakes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Quinn Scaglione

    I agree with virtually everything, though if I had to stretch for a disagreement, I would choose the statement, “while I do not disagree with those who argue that Hollywood also privileges the perspectives of whites, I find in my analysis of the high school films that a social class lens better explains the data than a lens of race.” I believe this is too fast of a dismissal to make in regards to the strong favoring of the white perspective in American coming of age, high school films. Though the highlighting of the middle class perspective is inarguably present and ingrained in the genre, this “standard middle class” experience being referenced time and time again is vastly different for those who are not white. An important distinction is that this genre is focusing not only on the middle class experience, but on middle class white teenagers. To separate the lens of race from that of social class is to neglect a genre specific history of discrimination in films depicting school age teens.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I found it difficult to find something to disagree within Bulman's work. Every evidence that was presented sounded solid to me, at least through my own lived experience. I did however find Bulman's analysis on popular culture and how we as a society perpetuate it very interesting. Bauman stated that " part of the pleasure of popular culture is that it is popular-that others are experiencing the same cultural product that we are experiencing." And I found this to be interesting as now more than ever with the rise of social media we are sharing our interests at a grander scale than ever previously thought. Especially when it comes to apps like Letterboxd that exclusively deal with discussion of movies between an audience of like minded peers, the ability to share popular culture is stronger than it ever was before.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don't think I have any stark disagreements with Bulman, but if I had to change something I think it would be his categorizations of art on the third page. They talk about pop culture as consisting of creative art, and commercial interests as two forces that both contribute to popular culture. Although this is an accurate description of media and content as a whole, I would argue that in popular culture there doesn't exist creative art without at least some influence of commercial interest. Like the previous reading talked about, popular culture combined with today's technology is a recipe for commodification. Originality and creativity may have been able to provide mainstream works of art in the past, but that line has gotten blurry as time moves forward. I think that at this point in history, at least in America, you'd be hard pressed to find content that is considered part of popular culture but isn't influenced by commercial interests in any way.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The passage from "Using the Movies to Make Sense of Society: A Sociological Introduction" by Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. and others makes an argument that movies, despite being works of fiction and fantasy, can provide insights into the realities of a particular society. However, one might disagree with this perspective.

    Reason for Disagreement: While it is true that movies can reflect certain aspects of the society in which they are produced, it's essential to recognize that movies are primarily a form of entertainment and storytelling. They often prioritize dramatic or commercial elements over strict accuracy or sociological representation. Therefore, it's a stretch to claim that movies reveal more about a society than the "reality" of their subjects.

    Counter-argument: Movies are a product of creative interpretation and often exaggeration. They may contain stereotypes, clichés, and sensationalized portrayals that don't necessarily reflect the nuanced complexities of real-life social issues. Sociological research, on the other hand, relies on empirical data, rigorous methodology, and systematic analysis to understand social phenomena accurately. While movies can provide some insights and provoke discussions about society, they should not be considered a primary or authoritative source for sociological research.

    In summary, the disagreement lies in the extent to which movies can be regarded as reliable sources for understanding society. While they can offer certain truths and insights, they are fundamentally works of fiction designed for entertainment, and sociological research is a more rigorous and accurate approach to studying social reality.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I did not find anything in this chapter that I disagreed with. However, I found it very interesting when it was mentioned that film reflects the culture to the extent that the artists that create the films are a product themselves in that culture and they are trying to convey something about the social world. This was interesting to me because I did not realize how deep the film industry could get. I would understand if it was a genre revolving around nonfiction topics or a documentary. Growing up, I would always think that the directors in movies were just creating different movies that cater to the public in order to boost their popularity. There are a various movies that are created in order to deliver a message about the real world and society as a whole. However, after thinking about it a bit more, I realize that there are various different themes that are embedded in different genres even if the movie is a comedy or even horror. Seeing this new perspective in film has opened my eyes in terms of how and why they created those movies for us to watch. There is always a deeper meaning to everything.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Like most of my peers, I couldn't find anything in this Chapter that I necessarily disagreed with. I would say that classifying school movies as Urban, Private, or Public is probably the easiest way to encompass all of them into digestible categories. If I'm being honest, I didn't particularly find anything in here interesting. I thought a few of the ideas were underexplained at times and left a need for some more information. Though I find movies written about school entertaining, they typically don't do much for me, and I feel as if those feelings may have limited my interest in the article.

    ReplyDelete
  10. When reading over Bulman's work I find it quite difficult to disagree with what he was saying. In the movie world it is there goal to make compelling stories that will attract and hook the viewer. That even means when producing a movie about a nonfiction topic will be almost like flushed out deep or blown a little out of proportion. I found very interesting the talk of individualism in his text and how the different social groups really are able to give a different perspective in these movies. Amaria mentioned a movie like Dope, where you see the main character just trying to survive in a tough neighborhood but shows how easily young people can get roped into the wrong crowd. That is just one example of the movie industry being able to have different meanings behind there movies even in the most unlikely of ways.

    ReplyDelete
  11. maggi hubbard
    Reading the article I didn't find much I felt was wrong or that I disagreed with. In Busman's article I feel like he does a good job at showing how many films exaggerate a false narrative of high school or middle school when it comes to class and race.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Emmie Weatherholtz-
    Similar to what we discussed in class, I disagree with how Bulman views urban schools. It feels as if there is something he is hesitant to add into the conversation that might be crucial to talk about. Which leads to the question of why are we so hesitant to talk about race in our school system or in pop culture? I think adding this piece of the conversation into his chapter would make for some more fufilling conversations.

    ReplyDelete
  13. After our conversation in class. I also really disagreed with how Bulman decided to categorize the different movies into specifically urban, suburban public, and private schools. Even though he is able to confront the fact media centers the high school experience around white teenagers, he seemingly ignores it and shifts the view to be class. Talking about the difference in portrayals of white teenagers versus people of color in high school movies would have been insightful information.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Well not me finding out a month later I never submitted my blog post. There was not really anything I disagreed with when it came to bullman because I use movies to help me make since of the world. It isn’t always healthy to live your life through tropes but they are real. Schools are different based on money and location but as you said in class what make it a little wrong is he isn’t trying to reference social class but he is talking about race. I don’t agree with beating around the bush.

    ReplyDelete
  15. There wasn't anything in the article that I felt was wrong or that I disagreed with, I think Bulman did a decent job of demonstrating how many movies depict a misleading story of high school or middle school in terms of class and race in his piece.

    ReplyDelete
  16. There wasn't anything that I disagreed with directly. Typically during these times people in school are trying to figure themselves out and what makes them different from the rest of society. One thing I think that should have been included would have to be race because that has a lot to do with what type of education one is receiving .

    LeiLani Brewer

    ReplyDelete
  17. Jadyn Cooke
    I didn't really see anything to disagree with in this. Busman article does a good job at showing how many films show an unrealistic view of high school or middle school when it comes to class and race.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I would have to disagree with the first sentence of this chapter, “Sociologists don’t often study films.” He says they study “social reality” instead of “social fantasy.” This doesn’t align with his later claims, when he suggests “films both reflect and shape culture.” Sociologists study social patterns, in which they would not be able to ignore the influence of film on social life. It's hard to imagine that sociologists simply didn’t acknowledge the worldwide shock of the “I am your father” debacle, or even the more recent uptake in interest of girl culture after the Barbie movie’s success. Additionally, he also claims that film analyses are based on smaller samples of films and “arguments often delve no deeper than the author’s interpretation of the ‘text’ of the film.” As a humanities major, I was a little hurt reading this. But genuinely, every review and discussion of literature and films I’ve been a part of has started with historical and cultural context around the text or the author’s life, anything that might have made an influence on the writing itself.

    ReplyDelete

August 28…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...