Tuesday, August 22, 2023

October 9… Bulman Revisited

Think back to Bulman’s ideas about Hollywood and high school. If possible, share something that you think he got right and also provide critique of some aspect of his ideas. 

20 comments:

  1. Danielle Hall:
    In terms of Bulman chapter two, I agree with him that many films about high school discuss a universal dream of what America looks like and have a sense of heroism. That being said, I disagree with the population that Bulman argues films focus on, especially in terms of class. While we have already mentioned the problematic nature of Bulman discussing class over race, I am critical of a different part of his findings. He believes that Hollywood focuses on the lives of the middle class because the middle class has become the common American experience. It would honestly be great if this were the case, but I personally do not think it is, although it may have been in 2015. In my social work classes, we discuss the fact that the working class is growing to be the largest social class, but most people believe they are a part of the middle class because there is not a super clear definition. I feel as though working-class experiences demonstrate the true American experience, and I think that movies about schools show that too after having watched a few films about the education system. Many teachers and students portrayed are clearly struggling financially and working hard to get by. Teachers have to pick up extra jobs, students have to prioritize things other than school, etc. I think the majority of our society can relate to these obstacles, which is why these types of films have become more prominent as time goes on. There are definitely high school movies about more financially comfortable individuals, demonstrating the universal dream. I think people enjoy watching these for entertainment, but that does not mean they can relate to the characters in that way. The middle class may still be a part of the American Dream, but unfortunately, that does not make it the American experience.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bulman is correct that possibility and individualism in high school films greatly correspond with America's belief that people can make choices that lead to success. The middle class is also used a lot in these films because that is what most people consider themselves. However, as time passes, this is becoming less and less truthful as the middle class is shrinking due to the economic inequality that is becoming more and more apparent in our society. It does bring the question, though, do most Americans consider themselves middle class because these films push it as the norm for most citizens? I think Bulman does lightly touch this subject by talking about the middle class is considered to be the American experience, but that is becoming less common. He considers people in the middle class with white-collar jobs and bachelor's degrees, but even those people are struggling. Because of this, I believe Bulman is wrong for calling it the American Experience. Though, as we do watch those kinds of high school Disney-like films as "feel good" movies, I do not believe many people relate to them as much as people relate to high school movies about struggle.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Michelle:
    I think Bulman is right in saying that expressive individualism is the dominant philosophy of the middle class (especially on film), but I don't think his application of it is quite as clean as he makes it out to be. He says that middle class Americans have fewer ties to "community, history, and tradition" than lower class Americans do, but I think this might be an oversimplification/another way that his analysis is weakened by refusing to engage with race. I can't really speak for any other cultural communities, but middle-class Black Americans do still have strong cultural ties, and making this known has always been a community effort. Since Black culture is viewed as the negative opposite of white middle class sensibilities, a lot of Black middle and upper class organizations like the NPHC and older Northern social clubs have historically been focused on presenting individuals as counterexamples in order to raise the esteem of the community. This also has a history in film: many films about the Black middle class all the way back to Oscar Micheaux's Within Our Gates have worked with this goal in mind. Like a lot of Bulman's ideas, there's some application for the idea of individualism as a dominant ideology, but he kind of paints it with too wide a brush.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that individualism is a big part of high school movies but not exactly as a way to show demographics. I think Bulman may not fully understand the social classes such as middle class. Middle class ranges anywhere from 40,000-100,000 so people on the higher end of that spectrum may be seen as rich but are still middle class. The lower end of that spectrum may be seen as poor but is still middle class. People who make lower middle class money may be in a lower costing area but that doesn’t make them in poverty. Also the idea that good teachers are in lower class schools and bad teachers are in middle and upper class schools. Bad teachers can be anywhere but so can good teachers. I think bulman may have been right for his times but not exactly for right now.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bulman's ideas about Hollywood and high school provide valuable insights into how American culture and society are reflected in the portrayal of high school life in films. One aspect he gets right is his analysis of the dominant theme of individualism in most high school films. He highlights how adolescents in these films are expected to transcend various limitations and social constraints to express themselves as individuals. This theme of individualism is indeed a common thread in many high school movies, emphasizing the importance of personal growth and self-expression. However, there is also a valid critique to be made regarding Bulman's analysis. He tends to categorize high school films into three subgenres based on social class - urban, suburban, and private school films. While these distinctions are relevant to some extent, they may oversimplify the complexity of the genre. High school films often incorporate a blend of themes and characters from different social backgrounds, making it challenging to neatly categorize them solely based on social class. Additionally, Bulman's analysis does not consider the evolving landscape of high school films and how they may have changed over time, especially beyond his 2001 book publication. Briefly touching upon the films mentioned - "Dangerous Minds", "Class Rank", and "Lady Bird". "Dangerous Minds" falls into the category of urban school films, portraying the story of a teacher who strives to make a difference in the lives of her students in a challenging urban environment. It aligns with Bulman's idea of the teacher-hero offering salvation in a culture of poverty. "Class Rank" and "Lady Bird" can be seen as suburban school films, with "Class Rank" exploring the dynamics of students in a suburban high school and "Lady Bird" focusing on the coming-of-age experiences of a young woman in a similar setting. These films may resonate with Bulman's notion of expressive individualism, as they emphasize personal growth and self-discovery. Overall, Bulman's analysis provides valuable insights into the portrayal of high school in American films, particularly regarding the theme of individualism. However, his categorization based on social class may oversimplify the genre's complexity, and his analysis could benefit from considering changes in high school films over time. The films you mentioned, each falling into different subgenres, offer diverse perspectives on high school life, further highlighting the rich and evolving nature of this genre in Hollywood.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Forgot to put my name Emaire :)

      Delete
  6. After revisiting Bulman's work, I have to admit his descriptions of the main types of films set in high schools are pretty accurate. However we have talked about in class the inaccurate title of Urban schools not taking place in the city but instead taking place in a lower income area with mostly people of color, the way Bulman described the story structure matched up well to me. I do agree that most films in this genre seem to follow a teacher's journey to save and inspire their students, especially in Freedom Writers, the film I watched. I also watched Clueless and I would agree that this film, focusing on students at a public school, drew more attention to individuality in a student's coming-of-age formula. This film portrayed school as more of a setting or a small obstacle, instead focusing on the high schooler's own personal journey. As for the last film I watched, School of Rock, I found it harder to categorize it under Bulman's categories. However I do recognize this is not a film centered around a high school, so maybe this would not disprove his theory. Bulman’s points suggesting most high school films fitting into certain formulas seem to hold up accurately to me. I would definitely agree that Bulman's idea of pop culture, Hollywood, and society all simultaneously impact each other. Especially in Clueless, I noticed how many of the film's portrayals seemed accurate to my own high school experience and I can now recognize my classmates mimicking the film's actions. For example the film depicts teachers and classwork as transactional or not to be taken seriously and this definitely reflected how many students viewed school at the time. Growing up seeing the teens in this film's attitude towards school definitely shaped how I viewed class as well. Pop Culture and society definitely influence each other back and forth.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thinking back to Bulman Chapter 1, the author's main argument revolves around how films depict poor, middle, and upper-class schools differently. However, the unifying force that brought all these films together was individualism amongst students and teachers. I believe Bulman was right to an extent. Within the films we dissected in class such as "Half Nelson" Individualism of the characters is very important as the characters must go on a journey of personal growth for themselves outside of the classroom. But the strong lines of class-ranking that Bulman believes in is hard to get behind. There are many factors that make a community of people come together, whether that's history, culture, or class. Bulman's belief that that a films depiction of a group of student's and their actions falls solely on their class, fails to comprehend the complexities of the characters background as we watched students from many class structures and history interact within the films we studied.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bulman talks a lot about how many highschool movies have the common theme individualism and coming of age. I do agree with this idea and I think it makes a lot of sense considering highschoolers are in the middle of childhood and adulthood. They have to figure themselves out. However I do not agree with all the the stereotypes within these movies, this main idea only comes into play with the middle class. Upper and middle class have different main ideas, but I think that any class could focus on this main idea.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think that High School movies are not entirely accurate, even when they try to. Then tend to get very cheesy and unrealistic for the comedy storytelling, but they can be based on real life experiences of high school students.

    ReplyDelete
  10. As we talked about in class, I think Bulman's dismissal of race as a key factor to consider in the purposes of education and indiviudalism is the biggest flaw in his analysis. In Lean on Me, the discussion of race is of upmost importance to the main character, the principal of the school. Through individual examples, the movie shows how the intersectionality of race and income and community are integral to a student's learning capacity at school. The research I did for the reflection paper that I wrote about the movie also showed how beyond the film, the reality of racial relations are complex but incredibly important to the unfolding of the real story that the film was based on. In order to understand education, we have to not only acknowledge but deeply explore the impact of social structures such as race and class.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Looking back at Bulman's ideas & comparing them to the films watched for class, I saw a big theme in individualism. I believe he did a good job depicting individualism & making it one of his key points about the average American high-school film. Bulman wrote much about adolescence & what that means in American culture specifically. However, something that he kept mentioning was the middle class. He seemed to focus on middle-class adolescents more than anything. Sure, a lot of popular high-school films, depict middle-class or upper-middle-class students, for example, Ferris Bueller's Day Off, but Bulman would be completely missing a key point if he didn't go over what life is like for a young individual of lower socioeconomic status. When thinking about Freedom Writers, mostly all of the students were of lower class & had to face harsh day-to-day struggles. Furthermore, Bulman brushed off anything to do with race. Race has much to do with how a student becomes individualistic. It's important to bring up the issues of race & lower-level classes because not everyone grows up the same way.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I do appreciate Bulman's perspective on individualism in films, and I agree with him to some degree. I think film and media can be subjective, and different people may have varying interpretations and opinions on the same topic. I agree with Bulman that individualism is an important theme in films and that it helps emphasize the uniqueness and independence of characters. I do question Bulman's point that most Americans fit into certain demographics based on class and race. I definitely understand his point and I agree to some extent certain character archetypes are common in movies. I just don’t think that everyone necessarily identifies with those archetypes. Bulman made a valid point though, as movies often try to depict a range of characters that appeal to a diverse audience.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Bulman's ideology regarding Hollywood and how it has affected society and the school realm has provided great insight on why things have developed within those two subjects. He believes that Hollywood plays an immense role in how our nations views society, which is something I agree with greatly. He also has mentioned the portrayal of poor urban schools and high elite private schooling through films and how that can provide a misconstrued perception of education in the real world. Although this is true to some degree, I do believe that there are some films that accurately depict what happens within those types of schools and how they truly function in reality. Yes, there are countless movies that exaggerate how children from different kinds of schooling act in the real world, but I would not say that they all have that same impact.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thinking back to Bulman's beliefs upon the individualism in different school systems. I agree that the effect of films have an impact on students. Negatively, stereotypes are definitely shown throughout films that might box students of different groups that shouldn't be forced into. Positively these films can show students who they are and want to imitate in certain ways. In general, I still agree with most of what Bulman preaches about education.

    ReplyDelete
  15. One thing Bulman got right would be that individualism is a common theme in high school movies. In most high school movies students are supposed to overcome their odds and be true to themselves. The path to their success or fulfillment is found in the hearts and mind of each person. Something I would critique would be how he doesn't really mention race as an important aspect of high school films, when race plays a big part in how people are depicted in films.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Jadyn Cooke
    Hollywood shows high school in a light that could be good or bad depending on what type of thing it's trying to show. Though it mostly shows high school in a bad unrealistic light. It shows high school as being a bad thing where you will mostly have trouble fitting in because of how the different groups of students and the possible bullies.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I agree that individualism is a big thing in high school as depicted in many films that we have seen. Bulman does a good job in portraying how people find their individualism specifically in high school. I feel as though that the point he is trying to make is that many Americans find themselves during this time because they are being exposed to so much. One thing Bulman should have elaborated more on was the different experiences of the many social classes.


    LeiLani brewer

    ReplyDelete
  18. As we have mentioned before in class, Bulman's whole thing on individualism is something that can see existing in high schools and hollywood depictions of high school. Many lessons you learn while in high school tend to be centered around being true to your self and understanding yourself as an individual. Although his individualism idea may be true his idea of centering race over class is something I could critique. Ignoring race puts people of color in a box because he would be solely talking about white people and their class experience and not everyone's experience is the same. Race is more apart of your individualism than your class, so it is worth mentioning along with people's class and their experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Looking back, Bulman does speak on the recurring theme we have encountered in these films, with the heightened stereotypes of both students and teachers as filmmakers work to fit in the truths of high school into a two hour film. I disagree that they couldn’t have done a better job, but it makes it less frustrating to think about it as the small snippet they had to work with. He also speaks on genre films and the types of genres or types of movies within a genre that continue to get produced due to popularity within the audience, box office, etc. As much as we can cringe at certain trope seen repeatedly in these movies, I think he’s right to point out that they are made for reasons outside of a producer’s independent intentions, but rather a larger audience’s want to see it.

    ReplyDelete

August 28…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...