React to day 1 of our documentaries module. One theme of day 1 is that while many docs strive to be factual, they their truths are shaped by those who make them. How did the class session relate to how you think of documentaries? Feel free to discuss whatever you think makes sense here...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 28…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about an...
-
React to day 1 of our documentaries module. One theme of day 1 is that while many docs strive to be factual, they their truths are shaped by...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
When I think of documentaries, I usually think of history, nature, or crime documentaries. It was my first time looking at a reality show as a documentary. However, even though they are similar, I would still not call a reality show a documentary. They both occur in the real world, but documentaries are more about pushing a subject or making you think. Most of the time, documentaries have sources, whether it be the people whom the documentary is about or experts on the subject. A documentary generally feels more factual and easier to call out when they get their information wrong. However, I believe both are similar when using music and effects to make you feel a certain way. I just think reality TV pushes it more to the extreme.
ReplyDeleteDanielle Hall:
ReplyDeleteI have always been drawn to documentaries showing the experiences of vulnerable communities, which relates to my career passions as a social work major. In the past, I do think that I looked at these films as factual, and I would use them as a means of educating myself in order to be able to better help and advocate for others (which I still do, but I am more cautious and reflective). More recently, I have recognized that this is not the case because the filmmakers are producing their documentaries from their perspectives, including any biases they may have. For example, I recently watched a documentary about the ethics of fur for fashion, and the woman who produced the film showed herself stealing farmers’ sheep. This is an illegal activity, yet she was able to make it seem like she was not doing anything wrong since she was in control of what was being shown. While some filmmakers do intentionally use their platform to spread their beliefs like that example, I think some directors genuinely try to show the facts. That being said, I think it is honestly impossible for a documentary to lack any bias because, as we discussed in class, they are produced by humans who have a limited amount of time to make a point and determine how they are going to go about doing so. This is true for anything we consume, which is why it is so important for us to not just accept everything we see and hear. Additionally, our class session really made me think about what makes a documentary a documentary. One definition is that they are “rooted in actuality,” which sounds a lot to me like “based on a true story.” Many of the movies we watched this semester were based on a true story, but they certainly were not documentaries. It was mentioned that documentaries can have reenactments, are from an artist’s viewpoint, etc., and these aspects describe movies based on true stories too. From my perspective, it kind of feels as though documentaries are what they are because of their vibe. There are certain aesthetic choices filmmakers make that tell the viewer that they are watching a documentary. These distinctions are really interesting to me, and I hope the specific decisions documentarians make become clearer throughout this unit as we look deeper at documentaries.
I think documentary movies and docuseries's, along with reality tv is sorta real. It's not always real because not only can some of the things the people say are sometimes scripted, but sometimes the documents, which are pictures and videos of people, places, and other things, including interviews with some of the people, can be edited in a certain way, and sometimes even AI generated. It can be risky and hard to identify what is real and what isn't when it comes to documentaries and reality tv.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed our first day of the documentary unit. When thinking of documentaries I first, think of non-fiction. Though documentaries are non-fiction, it doesn't mean they can't be scripted. Especially thinking about reality TV, I think most viewers don't really realize that those types of shows are actually documentaries in themselves. They use key elements of documentaries, such as interviews. Though they are a much more dramatized & scripted version, they can still be thought of as documentaries. Even in a typical documentary, the interviewee could have biases, or be lying when they talk about the subject of the film. The documentarian as well could have bias when trying to portray the message they are trying to. It's hard to find any documentary 100% truthful & unbiased, however, I still think they feel more real than any other sort of genre we see.
ReplyDeleteMaya Payne
ReplyDeleteAfter class I started to think about documentaries and why certain pieces of media are categorized as documentaries and some on the other hand are not, such as our discussion of if we think reality tv is a form of a documentary, to further analyze we were shown the bachelorette, and in my mind I would agree that the bachelorette is a documentary, but not the uptight or melancholy way, but to show the emotions each contestant is going through to find love. Throughout the show one person states and shows why they should be the one for the bachelorette, thus being shown one-on-one confessionals during the season, competitions to show who was going to get the rose and ultimately go on a date, to then showing us if the one of the men gets to go back to the fantasy suite. This style of reality tv, to me, is of a documentary. Furthermore, during class we were given a definition of what a documentary was and when the term "documentary" was created, all of this information made me think of how many documentary’s I watch on a monthly basis because of the non-fiction aspect and how each film gives me insight into why an event happened, such as true crime or how I can stay informed on a particular topic, for example the documentary on how apple face ID is inherently racist.
I talked to my table group about this a little bit, but I couldn't stop debating myself on if dramatizations of real events could be considered a documentary. I'm thinking in specific about Band of Brothers, which opened every epsisode with an interview of a few elderly men, who not until the end of the show were relvealed to be the main "characters" of the show. The events DID happen, but the filmmakers could and did change major parts of the story. For example, there was a person in the show who was depicted being killed in combat, but in reality he made it out of the war and passed in the 80s.
ReplyDeleteWhen looking at documentaries they are some of the few tapes in the media that are the closes things to non-fiction. It was also interesting to notice aspects of documentaries that other genres of televisions take and incorporate into their own shows. The example of the Bachelorette we used in class was a key example of aspects of documentary scenarios being using in reality TV.
ReplyDeleteWhen I think about documentaries I always think of the definition being an informational movie on a specific topic, that’s why they don’t interest me as much. Certain documentaries on topics that I care about or care to learn more about make them enjoyable. The discussion in class on monday made me think about the elements of what makes a good documentary and that, although you may not think about it, in media (reality tv) they have specific elements that make them be considered as a documentary. Even though, as we discussed in class, reality tv can be considered as a documentary, I can not see them being documentaries. Especially based off my definition of a documentary.
ReplyDeleteI wasn’t surprised to see the types of documentaries my peers watch as I enjoy similar genres like true crime. I would watch documentaries on occasion, but only really for entertainment purposes or background noise while I’m focusing most of my attention on other hobbies. I never really thought about what makes a documentary a documentary. At first when watching the bachelorette advertisement in class I did not consider it a documentary due to the acting, staged performances, and use of drama over reality. However after defining what effects and commonalities documentaries tend to have such as interviews and purpose of documenting live events and reactions, my definition of documentaries has widened. Similar to what makes a film a film or what makes a comic a comic, university classes have made me question the purposes and definitions of media. There are always outliers and exceptions when defining a term. Despite documentaries being hard to define, I believe finding the reoccurring tropes and stylized formats that this genre often uses can help us better understand the medium, determine the messages they wish to share with us, and analyze their documentation (especially to uncover what they say about education for this class).
ReplyDeleteThe way i think of documentaries was one that followed a simple idea to prove a point and show footage of that point. But after class i realize that documentaries are much more about just trying to showcase information that they want to share and making it entertaining enough for people to want to sit down and enjoy whats being shown. This completey changed how i looked at them since i typically viewed them as just nonfiction movies but they are more nonfiction stories.
ReplyDeleteMichelle Ghee:
ReplyDeleteOne thing that stuck out to me about our discussion of documentaries was how hard it was to draw line around what documentaries actually are, especially when that definition is challenged by things like reality TV. For me, I think intent of the filmmaker and perception of the audience both inform what constitutes "documentary". If the filmmakers are setting out to document the truth + reality and the audience is genuinely lead to believe that what's being depicted is the the truth, then that (to me) puts it a little bit closer to documentary than fiction. Obviously, this truth-seeking can be informed by the biases of the filmmakers, but I think that a documentary can also document the biases of the creators. If documentaries are "creative treatments of reality", then I think part of the creative aspect is the worldview of those making it.
I think the class session was very beneficial to my understanding of documentaries and their variety in style. Biases and beliefs of actors, directors and producers heavily influence the meanings of documentaries. I also enjoyed the discussion about what exactly is considered a documentary and what is not. From my understanding, there seems to be a large grey area. In my opinion, documentaries are one of the best forms of representing a reality, true or not.
ReplyDeleteSomething our class made me realize was that I only thought of documentaries as educational or story telling. It was the first time the idea of reality tv being a documentary was presented to me. I agree with the idea because reality tv documents real people’s everyday life, and has interviews with the cast members to get further analysis of what is happening in their lives.
ReplyDeleteI wasn’t in class Monday but documentaries have never been something I enjoyed. I always saw documentaries to be almost like reality tv shows. Sometimes the documentaries are about factual events that we don’t know every detail on so some things good be dramatized such as the war documentaries set during the American revolution that are so dramatic. You do have characters, music, a topic, and actors in both documentaries and reality tv. Documentaries are meant to be taken seriously but like theater it is the tragedy or serious work of art to mockumentaries comedy. There is also interviews in both reality tv and documentaries. Honestly there isn’t a big different between tv for entertainment based on reality and our nonfiction based tv based on reality. When you realize that it makes you question what is factually based when watching. You can also tell what was more important to the producers, directors, and the creative team.
ReplyDeleteI had never really thought about the distinction between reality TV and documentaries, and how they are both presented as similar forms of content that supposedly depict real events. However, they each have differences that affect their accuracy to reality. Documentaries often tell a story that has already happened, meaning that they are piecing together a narrative by collecting content from various sources or recreating the story in their own way. Either way, they are unable to show the complete reality of most situations they cover. Reality TV shows are more like observational studies or experiments in that they move forward in time as the show is being created. The process of monitoring the subjects manipulates the results of the study. In this case, reality shows may be able to make accurate accounts of what happens if they have honest editing, but the conclusions and results of those shows can't be generalized outside of that environment, meaning that they don't depict what would actually happen in real life. I think that many people are aware that no form of documentary or reality show is going to directly reflect reality, but there are a lot of factors (even besides the ones mentioned) that manipulate the content much more than we realize.
ReplyDeleteAs someone who doesn't regularly watch documentaries I found our discussion to be interesting as I never would have considered reality tv as documentaries before. I typically see documentaries as an entertaining yet educational non-fiction film. I always figured that the topic had to be something informational, but with reality tv we are still documenting real life events even if they are meant to be purely for entertainment. We could call into question the possibility that film crews are pushing the events of the show to take place making it a fictional perspective of these real people's lives.
ReplyDeleteIf so, can we say for certain that these events reflect reality and are truly documentaries. (The website glitched and posted my submission before I was finished)
DeleteI always thought that I never really cared for documentaries, but our discussion in class about reality tv was an eye opener. I never considered how there can be some overlap between reality tv and documentaries. I think there are a lot of “documentary-style” reality tv shows, like "Survivor," which is literally one of my favorite shows. Shows like “Survivor" combine elements of unscripted drama with real-life situations and human interactions. I think overall, some reality shows may incorporate elements of documentary filmmaking, but are still aimed at providing entertainment rather than education. A lot of times shows that involve a competition may emphasize conflict or emotional moments for a dramatic effect.
ReplyDeleteI was not in class when we talked about documentaries however I have watched a handful of ones throughout my life. I have watched them on my own, or if one was on the tv at home, and sometimes even in school. Many peoples blog posts are about how they like crime documentaries which are the ones I like. I do not really like the ones I have watched in school. When I think of documentieries I think they are very dramatic and make the story seem so much more real
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed our conversation about documentaries from our class on Monday! I do not watch many of them frequently, but the discussion of whether is reality tv considered a documentary was interesting to me! I typically would associate the term documentary with something serious or educational, but by definition, reality TV can be labeled as documentaries as well! For this unit, I am excited to watch the documentaries we chose and to discuss them with the people in our group!
ReplyDeleteJadyn Cooke
ReplyDeleteWhen I think of documentaries, I think of them as an interesting educational way to learn about different topics. Seeing the images shown from whatever topic talked about helps viewers to visualize what is being taught and to help make associations when seeing or hearing about the topics in a different setting and to be interesting in a way you recall the information learned in the documentary.
When I think of documentaries, I think of a film dedicated to a specific, large event that has happened in real life. Usually, for historical or crime related events. Our class session made me realize that documentaries can be so much more than that. Documentaries can range from covering the simplicity of someone daily life to major historical events. The class made me understand that there are more to documentaries than I had anticipated.
ReplyDeleteMy experience with documentaries has been primarily, like others, with topics such as nature, crime, and occasional band documentaries. When I open the idea of documentaries up to reality tv the air around it changes completely. The concept of documentaries being tightly bound to truth and facts is altered to one that encourages dramatization - which is something I surprisingly enjoy. It’s nice to consider reality tv a subtype of documentaries because they surely feature real people and events to some degree. This raises the question of if documentaries have to be fully unbiased accounts of events. At what level of bias is a documentary considered reality tv?
ReplyDeleteSomething I realized in this class was that I only saw documentaries as an "educational movie" of sorts. But, I never thought about the possibility of reality tv being classified as a documentary. Now, I agree with this and I can see how reality tv can be a documentary, as it documents real life people in their daily lives and also interviews these people to get a more in-depth understanding of what's happening.
ReplyDeleteThis discussion has opened my eyes to the many different types of documentaries. I realized that many of the shows that i've watched and have been really interested in are set up like a documentary. which is just a way to provide information in a informative but interesting way enough to have people sit and watch it. Reality Tv is definitely a different take on the typical style of a documentary.
ReplyDeleteLeiLani Brewer
Documentaries have an interesting opportunity to tell stories in almost real time, with real people and real problems. However, the interests of those making a documentary are not always noble in their truth telling, and personal endeavors can often shine through in awkward ways. The line of real life and story telling is one that a documentary can balance, but we often see them sway farther into one side or the other.
ReplyDeleteA phrase that works very well with this idea is that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Any form of truth is so widespread that you can bend the lines in most cases. Documentarians exhibit a process of creating truth in their films. Their distinct choices of what to present to the viewer shape the opinions and thoughts of the viewer. Especially with something generally so expository like a documentary, the film is meant to make the audience feel something. While the aim could be to persuade, inform, etc., documentaries leave the audience with new knowledge, completely constructed with purpose. Documentarians create their story or truth to share the beauty of whatever that may be with their viewers.
ReplyDelete