Tuesday, August 22, 2023

November 15…Book Banning

Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about anything you want to think about/discuss related to the topic.

26 comments:

  1. Danielle Hall:
    https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/interactive/2023/florida-book-bans-school-rules/

    When we mentioned book banning in class, the focus was on Texas, as that is the state in which “New Kid” was banned, but the first state to come to my mind was Florida. This news story shares the perspective of a librarian in Florida, Tania Galiñanes. Unfortunately, Tania left her position as a librarian which she loved so much since she did not agree with the state’s and school’s decisions. While Florida’s recent conversations about banning books have been surrounding children’s sexuality rather than race, book banning, no matter the topic of fear, is a threat to democracy from my perspective. Books allow us to share different points of view and spark important discussions. Just because a student reads something does not mean their opinions will change. Humans have the capacity to critically think and determine for themselves what their beliefs are. I am sure that if a parent is worried about their children’s morals changing because of a book, they are going to change at some point or another regardless of whether they read that book or not. I do not blame Tania for quitting her job, as it is quite upsetting that this continues to take place today, but it is saddening to me that someone who cared so much about their job and the children felt the need to leave. I am worried about the future of our school systems if the educators and staff who are against things like banning books continue to leave. Schools shape our society, and our society will look very different (and bad) if book banning becomes the norm and only one voice is shown to our children. In terms of banning books like “New Kid,” in my opinion, if a white person feels attacked by this story, they are the problem and likely a racist individual. To be completely honest, I personally felt a lot better after reading the story because at least I know not to say things like that (although I do not think that was the intended message). I do understand limiting books based on age groups, as some people are not ready to read certain books yet developmentally. Books like “New Kid,” though, are not one of those books, and I think our legislators and leaders need to ‘do a lot of work on themselves’ if they think it is.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I could not find the video but not to long ago I saw this news clip of 4th graders discussing how their school library is getting rid of too many books all becasue of book banning. The children explained how they keep getting less and less options. These kids all loved to read as a hobby, I believe we should encourage kids to love to read. Reading is so healthy for someone and helps with their overall schoolwork and learning as a whole. Giving kids less options on what they can or can not read is just making kids want to read less. I understand their are adult books which are not appropriate for little kids but age appropriate books like new kid, or drama which include racism, and the LGBTQ community should not be banned just becasue they talk about those subjects.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When I began looking into any recent news in Banned Books, I was immediately hit with tons of news reports and articles about Pop Artist, Pink, giving away 2,000 banned books to her fans in Florida. Books are often banned in order to restrict people's access to certain ideas, actions, or lifestyles within stories, which makes a wide audience unaware of the story and the message's very existence. This censorship enforces only one belief or mindset instead of allowing people to see other perspective and points of view. Students should have access to many different subjects in order to learn and think for themselves. Pink is a very well known musical artist to both super fans and general audiences. Reaching people is exactly what banning books is trying to avoid, so Pink's wide audience is the perfect. I believe her actions will be very influential to all kinds of people, especially impressionable children who look up to her. Like we have learned in class, children are very influential and are at a pivotal part of their lives where learning from media like books is significant in their developing impressions of the world. Therefore actions like Pink's doing and books like New Kid are important to allow kids to have access to. Florida is also a great place for Pink to hand out these banned books as the state is often very restrictive about media involving topics like LGBTQ or people of color.

    ReplyDelete
  4. One banned book that I have read and thoroughly enjoyed is The Hate U Give. It is banned due to foul language, violence, and because it was thought to promote anti-police messages and the pushing of a social agenda. However, when I read the book in 9th grade none of these things stood out to me. The main thing I took in was the experience of the main character and the reality that she had to go through for being a black person in America. It helped open my eyes to new ideas and thoughts that I had not had before. It disgusts me that people want to ban books about race because it is such a prominent issue in todays world. If young people of color have to LIVE racist experiences why cant young white people HEAR about them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ^^Ella Kate; i forgot to put my name

      Delete
  5. https://www.texastribune.org/2023/10/11/texas-library-book-bans/
    Book bans are growing the most in Texas, where the bans are targeting mostly the LGBTQ, as well as children's books by Dr. Seuss and "No David" as well. It is also targeting the Jewish community by banning Anne Frank's diary. Some of the reasons are nudity, but also because Texas is a conservative state and conservatives are generally racists, anti-semetic, homophobic, and transphobic as well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. https://pen.org/more-than-300-titles-banned-in-collier-county-florida/

    Due to Florida's new bill, HB 1069, Collier County Public Schools has had to ban over 300 books. The new bill makes it so books must lack any sexual content and anything with sexual orientation and gender identity. This bill goes for everyone in 8th grade and below. The person who put the new bill into motion is republican representative Stanley McClain. This is one of many book bans happening in Florida, but this one significantly broadens what books have to be banned, and it's disturbing. I find it funny that a big part of what Republicans believe in is a lack of government control, especially with people's personal lives, but book bans are okay??? Shouldn't it be the parent's job to decide if a book is suitable for their child and decide it for THEIR child alone?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Michelle Ghee

    https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/27/us/maus-banned-holocaust-tennessee.html

    The discussion on book bans made me think of the ban in Tennessee on Maus last year. It's a book that deals with the rough edges of history in very frank terms, and was banned because of it. One quote from the article that stuck out to me was "We can teach them history and we can teach them graphic history. We can tell them exactly what happened, but we don't need all the nakedness and all the other stuff." For me, it's weird to think that if you're against the boldness and Maus and the relative gentleness of New Kid, then how do you expect history to be taught at all?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I decided to look into what was happening here in Virginia in regard to the topic of banning books. I think that in general, this subject is very upsetting to hear about. I am a firm believer that books are one of the best resources you can have, at any age, but especially for little kids. To hear about books that don't align with everybody's political or moral views being taken off shelves, and taking a learning opportunity away from young minds is heartbreaking. I found a list of 17 books banned in Hanover County which is just outside of Richmond. It ranges between books about stories of LGBTQ+ individuals, personal memories, stories about representation for POC, etc... Some supervisors have valid reasons for not wanting to expose children to certain topics such as drug abuse and sexual assault, however, not all of the books on this list fall into that category and some seem a little unnecessary to ban and take off the shelves.

    ReplyDelete
  9. https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/13/us/pink-gives-banned-books-at-concert-reaj/index.html
    In this article it talks about how pink decided to hand out over 2000 banned books at her concerts. She feel no one should be telling kids what to read especially not her kids just as she wouldn’t be told what to read. New kid is a good book that all kids should be able to read. If an adult can read what they want then kids should to especially since they let some books stay that are inappropriate like any original story of Disney characters. Books are given reading levels based on how well kids will understand them so why not label mature books for older kids. If they are good smart kids they should be able to read a book covering events happening in the world and understand. The things kids read that are being banned are also taught in history class and you can’t ban history just as you can’t erase it. Just supervise the kids like with movies that may be a little more mature. Banning a book doesn’t stop kids from reading the book or finding out things in the world it just makes them mad for feeling like stuff was hidden from them

    ReplyDelete
  10. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/19/texas-book-bans/

    This article discusses how Texas is the state with the most book bans, banning the most books in the nation. The targets of these bans are books that center on the topics of race, racism, and LGBTQ+ representation. I feel like Texas would be the type of place where a book like New Kid could potentially get banned, as the book is about race and racism, and how it ties into schooling. It shows all of the racist and stereotypical things he goes through.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This specific article spoke about books that were banned that were mostly targeted to young adults so middle/high school and beyond. The themes that typically are the ones to have LGBTQ+ themes or characters and Protagonists that are characters of color. When I think of the New Kid ban it doesn’t make sense because the themes in the book are not causing harm to anyone and in reality they are helping children of color see themselves in a different light. The fact that it was banned tells me that Texas does not value kids of color feelings compared to their white counterparts and that is the sad truth. Book Banning as a whole is a strong topic for me because I want to be a lower elementary teacher and many of the books that could be active learning tools and good books to read in my class library are banned because white people in power feel like they are demeaning to their kids or their ideas. If we are catering to white children/families we are moving backward in history and it’s honestly doing a disservice to those white children. There was a book that I saw on TikTok talking about family dynamics and it mentioned how some kids have two moms/two dads and some kids live with grandparents and so on. That book is a perfect way to introduce children to family dynamics in a way that they would genuinely understand but unfortunately, it was banned. The whole topic of book banning is so disappointing coming from a future teacher and I don’t want to see what comes next in life based on the direction we are heading currently.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://pen.org/report/banned-usa-growing-movement-to-censor-books-in-schools/
      the link^

      Delete
  12. https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/education/2023/11/15/iowa-releases-proposed-rules-for-law-on-banned-books-gender-identity/71584498007/

    This article speaks on a new Iowa proposed law that bans any book depicting "sexually explicit" acts while also placing restrictions on accommodating gender identity. This new law would require the removal of all books that depicts sex acts or discussion of sexual orientation or gender identity. This would also require all school administrators to tell a student's caregiver if the student is using pronouns that differ from their sex at birth. With the rise of anti-trans rhetoric across the United states, particularly in more republican dominated states. The removal of anything that could be deemed as LGBT+ was inevitably going to follow. Grouped in with anything "sexually explicit" in an attempt to depict that community as sexually devious to make their banning a more reasonable act. This is all in an attempt to "protect the kids," but with this new law Iowa is banning more than 1000 books. This information could be vital to a more educated and safer future for the people who will always be queer despite the constant outlaw of their existence.

    ReplyDelete
  13. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/09/19/texas-book-bans/

    Book bans have gradually become more and more prominent in society. This year, a few states have been banning books like "The Bluest Eye" and "Gender Queer: A Memoir". These books were deemed to be damaging toward students' education and parents did not feel as if it was appropriate for these books to be included in the curriculum. However, these books are anything but damaging, and provide extensive information about the LGBTQ+ community and the experiences of young black woman in society. It goes to show that the people banning these books want to shelter children from learning more about people who may not look and think like them which can become extremely catastrophic.It is extremely important that we provide children with as much insight as possible regarding these subjects even if parents and faculty may not "agree" with what is being read.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I saw a Youtube video the other day about a school board where a group called "Moms for Liberty" has been going on a campaign of banning books. This particular session was about the ban of the "Perks of Being a Wallflower", but over 50 other books were on the chopping block, including "Gender Queer". These books remind me of New Kid because they are about growing up and exploration. They may present flawed characters, but they represent reality for a lot of kids. Taking away that representation is incredibly harmful to a school and the purpose of education. One parent at the meeting called out the hypocrisy of Moms for Liberty for calling "Gender Queer" porn while also sending out images of the book pages to tens of thousands of people in the community. This would be a criminal act if they actually believed that the book contained porn.

    ReplyDelete
  15. https://abcnews.go.com/US/conservative-liberal-book-bans-differ-amid-rise-literary/story?id=96267846

    The ABC article I read went in detail about how book censorship is increasing and how both liberals and conservatives feel of the matter. This quote in specific stood out to me, ""It's shifting from parents and citizens giving lists to school boards, to laws," Friedman said. "And that's a really significant shift because there's a huge difference between a school board responding to parental ire and a school board responding to threat of punishment from the government."" I think it's kinda scary to think that some groups are getting the government involved and taking legal action for the ban of books. In my opinion, I think the ban of books is silly. It's not as if the book will simply disappear once it's banned. Some of the books on these lists truthfully don't have any explicit material that would not be suitable for kids, but rather they feature LGBTQ+ characters and themes, and are being banned. I think that is insane and super unfair to LGBTQ+ kids who may want to see someone like them in the literature they read. I believe if you don't want your child to read something that public school offers and if it's that big of a matter to you, you should look into homeschooling or private school options. It shouldn't get to the point where we are involving the government in what books out public schools teach. Sure, there are books out there that may not be appropriate for all ages, but I think with professionally trained staff there are ways we could resolve this issue. One being, school librarians making sure books students check out are age appropriate as kids check them out. Also, teachers being trained to properly discuss books to their class that may contain harsh themes. A lot of the books on the list are banned for containing racism, but I think it's important we talk about these topics as they are a very real reality for students across the nation, New Kid is one perfect examples.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Recently, a school district in Texas made headlines for its decision to ban a book from its libraries and curriculum. The book in question was "The Hate U Give" by Angie Thomas, which tells the story of a young black girl who witnesses the police shooting of her friend. The district cited concerns about "inappropriate language" and "mature content" as reasons for the ban. This decision sparked outrage among many students, parents, and educators who argued that the book is an important and powerful tool for promoting empathy and understanding about issues of race and police brutality. They pointed out that the book has won numerous awards and has been widely praised for its realistic portrayal of the experiences of black Americans. The controversy over book banning and censorship is not a new one. Throughout history, books have been banned or censored for a variety of reasons, ranging from concerns about indecency or blasphemy to political or ideological objections. However, the issue has become particularly contentious in recent years as the rise of social media and online communities has made it easier for people to express their opinions and organize campaigns to ban or censor books.
    One of the most high-profile cases in recent years was the controversy over the young adult novel "Thirteen Reasons Why" by Jay Asher, which was adapted into a popular Netflix series. The book and show tell the story of a teenage girl who takes her own life and leaves behind a series of cassette tapes explaining the reasons why. Critics argued that the book and show glamorized suicide and could be triggering for vulnerable young people, leading to calls for it to be banned or restricted. However, defenders of the book and show pointed out that they also offered an important opportunity to start conversations about mental health and suicide prevention. They argued that censorship was not the answer and that instead, educators and parents should engage in open and honest discussions with young people about these difficult topics. Ultimately, the issue of book banning, and censorship raises important questions about freedom of expression, artistic freedom, and the role of literature in society. While it is important to consider concerns about age-appropriateness and sensitivity to different cultural and religious beliefs, it is also vital to ensure that diverse voices and perspectives are represented in our libraries and classrooms. As author Neil Gaiman once said, "The only way that we can live is if we grow. The only way that we can grow is if we change. The only way that we can change is if we learn. The only way we can learn is if we are exposed. And the only way that we can become exposed is if we throw ourselves out into the open."

    Pilkington, E. (2020, December 18). Texas school district bans book about police brutality. The Guardian.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Jadyn Cooke
    Some book banning that happened where because of old racial stereotypes which people the stereotypes were based on where offended, and they were removed because of how thing changed and the stereotypes where no longer seen as okay. Other books that were banned recently are because of things that some don't want their children to see. I remember seeing a clip of a man reading an exert from a book in a kid's school that he wanted banned because of explicit content and he read it to the school board and was asked to stop not to soon after reading the exert because of the content.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Maya Payne:
    https://www.insidenova.com/headlines/parents-protesting-more-books-at-prince-william-school-libraries/article_369966c0-1cb7-11ed-89bf-635523369e14.html

    Within my county, Prince William, hasn't ban nor, put into place book banning on the bases of religion, gender or even race, unlike the surrounding counties, however recently, parents have demanded that sexually explicit books be banned from the library of public schools. Such as "The Giver" on the grounds of infanticide and euthanasia and What Riley Wore”, nevertheless books haven't been banned as of August 2023, but these books were placed in libraries from the recommendation of the the staff and students. On the other hand, the parents that are calling for these specific books to be banned are only opening the flood gates for them to pursue more books to be banned to cut off the line of knowledge that doesn't stop at white history, but topics and situations that expand far beyond and that are realistic to today's generation and what students face today.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I saw this tiktok of a librarian showing what her school library looked like, and a lot of the shelves were empty. I saw another tiktok showing what books were being banned (not sure where), and they were all books for kids of color. Some of them were books I enjoyed reading when I was younger, and it made me sad to think kids like me won’t be able to read books where they can’t see themselves in the main characters. The library in my elementary school was stacked with books, not an empty space in sight. To think about what an empty library would look like is sad and it's unfortunate that kids these days are being ripped of an opportunity to read certain books because basic topics are seen as too political.

    ReplyDelete
  20. A book that me and my group talked about was The hate U give and it was banned because its depiction of racism and anti-police views. For me personally I feel as though this book is a great educational piece that would be very beneficial for students to read and understand . Especially the specific time period the book was published during it was a lot going on pertaining police and people of color. And I feel as though the book is a good informational source.

    LeiLani Brewer

    ReplyDelete
  21. My hometown, Spotsylvania County, VA, has been faced with an ongoing book ban battle since 2021, when the school board was approached by parents concerned with the content in the book “33 Snowfish,” “Call me by your name,” why their child’s library showed more results when they searched “gay” versus “heterosexual,” and more. What ensued was interesting claims from the school board chair who claimed we should “burn those books,” and support from one other member in doing so. They voted that night to have librarians in the county do an unclear sweep of all books and flag ones with “explicit” content to be removed. In the next meeting over 100 students and faculties across the county came to comment on the absurdity of the call, and it was reversed. Here is an article from the time:
    https://www.wusa9.com/article/news/education/spotsylvania-school-book-ban-burning-33-snowfish-call-me-by-your-name/65-e38fc873-d85f-433e-9d16-3572682e4572
    However, recently they have begun to ban specific books, including Toni Morrison’s Beloved, The Song of Solomon, and The Bluest Eye, Looking for Alaska by John Green, The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky and more. On October 9 the Superintendent sent out a memo of 23 additional books to be removed to add to the 14 already on the list, and an aptly named right-wing news source, The Spotsy Wire, includes the memo and name-calling of the members of the board who opposed the movement.
    https://spotsywire.com/2023/10/10/23-explicit-books-removed/
    I think this example summarizes the climate surrounding the banning of books in most towns across the US, where despite the claims in the memo that “70% of parents” supported the ban, the community at large is actively and vocally against such policies.

    ReplyDelete
  22. https://www.nbc12.com/2023/11/28/75-more-books-banned-hanover-county-schools/

    I read an article about the recent banning of books in Hanover Public Schools. Hanover County school board decided to ban 75 books, including well-known works like “Forever” by Judy Blume, “The Handmaid's Tale” by Margaret Atwood, and others. One book that especially stood out to me was “The Perks of Being a Wallflower” by Stephen Chbosky. Apparently this book often faces challenges and bans in certain school districts due to its content which was pretty surprising to me. The book does include themes of sexual content and drug use, but it mostly discusses mental health. I’ve always thought of this book as a coming-of-age story, where the protagonist is just trying to navigate through high school. I understand wanting to protect kids from triggering or age-inappropriate content, but addressing real-life issues and seeing new perspectives is a must.

    ReplyDelete
  23. https://truthout.org/articles/report-attempts-to-ban-books-in-2023-are-outpacing-previous-year-by-20-percent/?gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiA4NWrBhD-ARIsAFCKwWsCOGhYALShpAKJMtIfrGUxvbIaP22stI4pWJaKs_0pUsv7uqsxdzUaAhqvEALw_wcB

    Personally, I'm typically always against book banning. I don't think the restriction of media is right unless it's horrific in a sense, but that's more of a thing based on age. Because of the internet, kids have seen unimaginable things, and typically not of their own accord but due to an unexpected scroll across social media. I think personally I feel like the world is a place where you're often forced to learn things. I think preventing kids from reading books, especially due to racism or transphobia/homophobia is just unbelievably narrow-minded. I hope those people grow up? I'm not sure exactly what I hope for them.

    ReplyDelete

August 28…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...